
Loa was not just a good dog, but rather, the best dog. And I know that all dogs are good dogs, and all dogs are the best dogs; that’s just how dogs are. But the reality is, when I say it, I need you to understand I really mean it. Every dog is the best dog but Loa really was the best dog.
We got her when my son was very young. She was, of course, a shelter dog, because shelter dogs are the greatest dogs; we saw a bunch of dogs that day, including an excitable cannonball of a pitbull puppy that (in wanting to play) knocked our son back horizontally like, five feet, as if he were a henchman getting blown away as collateral shotgun damage in an Arnold Schwartzenegger movie. So that dog was not going to be our dog. But that day they said, “You’re also scheduled to see Peaches,” and we did not know who or what a Peaches was.
Peaches was this little red dog — a puppy, really, maybe nine months old, and she trotted out and diligently followed behind our wandering child, keeping a protective distance but staying close enough to follow. She’d follow, then sit. Follow, then sit. Super cool, super chill. I drove her home, and all the while she kept trying to leave her seat and ride with me as I drove. Which wasn’t easy, but I managed. She helped drive me home that day. Always wanting to be with her people.

I’d argue that wanting to be with her people was her fundamental trait — the thing that drove her, always. Even now, up to the end, even with cancer hanging heavy on her poor muzzle, even when she couldn’t really see anymore or hear anymore, she knew where we were and would come to the room we were in. She would panic a little if we were out of sight — so we spent a lot of extra time being there, being present, and reassuring her with pets, touches, and extra snacks.
We named her Loa. We’d been to Hawaii a couple times and knew that Loa meant something between long and a lot, and she was both of those things — here she was, this long, gangly dog when she sprawled out, and a whole lot of dog. Not in a needy, too-much-to-handle way. She just had a lot of love to give and we had the love to give back. So: Loa.
She was always so good with our son. She was our dog, but also, his dog — they are, or were, the same age, after all. Loa was our first true family dog — we’d had dogs before, obviously. I brought a dog to our relationship, a gloriously hairy black Belgian sheepdog named Yaga. And my wife and I got a taco terrier, Tai, to join Yaga, and those two were fast friends. But Loa was the first for the whole family.
Tai, the chihuahua-fox-terrier, had found her one true best-friend-forever in Yaga. They were fast buddies, and she was like his little co-pilot. When he passed, something went away in her, too, and she did not want to be bonded to anyone or anything new. She tolerated our child, but really didn’t like Loa at all. This, despite Loa loving Tai oh so very much. Loa just wanted to hang with her new little friend. Tai just wanted to plot a complicated murder. (Chihuahuas gonna chihuahua.)
(For reference, see if you can spot the aforementioned murder-plotter.)

So when Tai passed, it seemed time to get Loa a new friend. And, as it turned out, a sister — in spirit, if not literally. Enter: Snoobug.

We got Snoobug at the same shelter. And again we saw a number of dogs that day and had Loa with us to take the temperature — and she had a blast with all the dogs because that was Loa. Loa got along with everybody. She had infinite love to give. Any of the dogs could’ve been a match for her, really.
But when we got in the room with Snoobug, the two sniffed each other, gave some licks, and then both just laid down together. Like they’d always known each other. So Snoobug came home with us, and they were bonded after that. They went out together, slept in the same bed together, ate together. It’s why we call them sisters — it’s like they grew up in the same litter.
(That photo of the two of them above is, of all the dog photos I’ve taken, the one I love the most. Sometimes a photo really captures a spirit and sometimes it doesn’t, but that one does so well it feels almost supernatural to me. I note too in that photo that Loa was definitely the dominant dog in the pairing, but played like she wasn’t. She was a gentle beast.)
I’m sobbing like a fool as I write this. Funny I guess how we sometimes cry more over our pets than we do some people. Maybe that’s not strange. Our pets are with us so much, so often, and they’re these like… little perfect pure beings. They don’t mean us any harm. They’re an unalloyed good. They want to love and be loved. And be fed. Hot dogs, ideally.
Loa’s eaten a lot of hot dogs in the last couple weeks. Like, an unreasonable amount. They weren’t something she was supposed to eat because of — well, I’ll get to that in a minute. But when you’re terminal with cancer, you get all the hot dogs you goddamn jolly well want. Hot dogs and turkey breast lunchmeat and even today she shared a peanut butter and jelly sandwich with me. It’s one of the things I’m glad about — she was still eating, drinking, sleeping well. And I know that wouldn’t last forever.
Loa almost died once before, big-time. She’d had bladder stones — and as it turns out, was prone to making them, a mobile canine bladder stone factory. She also loved to get on her back and have you rub her tummy, and our vet posited that this position was also perfectly optimal for working bladder stones into bad positions.
So we gave her meds and food to break them up, but one got lodged in her urethra and, stoic dog as she was, she failed to let us know this until one day we found her standing in the kitchen, shaking violently and going to the bathroom on herself. Which she didn’t do! She never, ever, ever went to the bathroom in the house. (Not even now, with all her systems shutting down — she dutifully made her way outside.)
So that day, we rushed her to the vet and she stayed there, in emergency care, for a week. But she pulled through. She had cancer, too, later on, but our groomer — thank your groomer! — caught it and we got it removed before it could do worse damage.
Though in the end, a new cancer, or maybe that cancer, still caught up to her. I guess that’s how it always goes with cancer. Still, fuck cancer. Dogs should be immune to it. Cancer shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near them.
Dogs are proof we live in a good and loving universe.
Dogs getting cancer is the proof that we don’t.
I hate this. I don’t want her to go. To be gone. It’s enough to make you never want to get another dog again. We will, of course. George Carlin was right — life is just a series of dogs. But the pain of this is so hard, so deep. This one fucking hurt, man. I feel like I’m dying inside. And yet it’s what we owe them at the end. It’s part of the price at the start. You make that deal the first day you take them into your house. Whatever it costs you then, it’ll cost you this at the end, and pay this price because it’s a mercy they can’t do for themselves — and ironically, often enough a mercy we can’t do for ourselves for each other, either, as people. But for them we can do it. And we have to do it. Even though it feels like the worst thing it is the best, most necessary thing. They give us so much. So this is the thing we owe.
She was ready to go. We weren’t ready for her to go. We would’ve kept her here forever if we could’ve. What a great dog.
Here’s why she was a great dog. The best dog.
She was calm. She was loyal. She was sweet. She was a complete goofusy doofus. She was fun. She was easy. She was a good guard dog. She was great on a leash and great off one, too. And she was smart, holy crap. Took almost no training and yet she never went in the house, knew how to knock at the door (or ring sleigh bells we put there) when she wanted to go out or come back in, she knew that if you said widdle paws at her she’d get down on her side and bring her two little paw-hands up to her muzzle and simulate petting, and that meant she was going to get petted so good, until you stopped, which meant she’d do it again, and you’d pet her, and she’d literally do this forever if you let her.

The cancer stole her in small pieces, though she didn’t suffer long with it. We had options to diagnose and treat, but none of them were really real — she was fourteen years old and any treatment would’ve been both costly in money but also costly to her, in pain. Her quality of life would’ve cratered and all just so we could’ve maybe, maybe had her around for a few months.
It was really only in the last two weeks that you could see the pieces of her going away — her eyesight, her hearing, her ability to smell stuff. The way the cancer in her mouth grew bigger. She’d sometimes appear lost in the room she was in. A kind of walking ghost phase. I tell myself now and told myself then that putting her to rest is literally that: letting her rest. The dog she is and was, well, went away. We were just giving her the peace she needed.
But god that fucking sucks. All the high-minded talk of what we owe them and the peace they need, it still fucking sucks that they get to come into our lives like this and be such perfect companions and friends and furry family members and then the universe gets to take them away again long, long before we are ready. It’s fucking stupid and it’s not fair, and cancer fucking sucks, and fuck all of this.

Okay, sure, she had a few less desirable traits. Did she eat poop in the yard? Sure. Who doesn’t? Would she, while on a walk or in the yard, be able to take a split-second’s worth of time to dart her head into the brush and come back with a baby rabbit or groundhog? Fine, guilty — she loved all creatures but preferred loving baby woodland critters with her teeth. (And seriously, she did this very very fast.) Did she, just the other day, in the throes of this cancer, somehow poop on a garter snake? Fact check: true. She pooped on a snake. I don’t know that this gets you any points over the rainbow bridge in the doggy heaven side of things, but she did it, and the snake was fine, if absolutely perturbed by it. Honestly, if you ask me, it was the snake’s fault. Loa was perfect. Shut up, snake. Get pooped on.
We don’t know what kind of dog she was, by the way. We never did any genetic testing. I always assumed she was somewhere in the middle of a hound slash retriever slash Rhodesian ridgeback DNA party. We just said she was a “red dog,” because she was a sweet red dog. Like Clifford if he was just a regular-size dog and not a gargantuan mutant.

I don’t really know how Snoobug is going to handle this. They were sisters, really, through and through.

But also, Snoobug is an absolute dipshit. And please understand I say that with full love in my heart. She’s the sweetest dipshit. But Loa had the brains. All the brains. Snoobug is like a dice cup — her brain is a random encounter chart in D&D. You shake it up and some days she doesn’t know how stairs work, or what side of a door to be on when it opens. She will literally change her habits every few months. So I don’t know what this will do to her. I hope, I guess, her brain just kind of forges ahead. Blissful ignorance. I know her heart won’t forget but her brain is definitely moth-eaten underwear and maybe that’s a nice protective way to be for yourself. We should all be so lucky.

I could talk about my dog all day and if you never met her I feel like that’s sad for you but maybe reading this you know her a teeny-tiny bit better. I can’t stand that she’s gone and I will miss her forever. She was the best dog we ever had — and no shade to out other dogs, they were the best too in their ways — and we’ll never see the like of her again.
We drove her home 14 years ago, and we drove her home again today.
I miss her.
I can’t stop crying at missing her.
I hate this, this fucking sucks.
Loa died today under an old, tall crabapple tree on a blanket set amidst a carpet of blooming violets. She was surrounded by her people. She is at rest.
She was a beautiful dog, so I feel it essential to show you with more photos.











And this is the last photo I took of her, from a good moment today:


Kat Howard says:
Oh, I am so sorry. What a very good dog.
April 29, 2026 — 4:54 PM
Beth says:
Oh Chuck, I’m so sorry. What a beautiful send off. You were lucky to have her, and she was lucky to have you, too.
April 29, 2026 — 4:59 PM
Laura Newhampshire says:
I’m crying my eyes out. For your Loa. For you and your family. For Snoobug. And for all of the Loas and Chucks and families out there. For every “best” we’ve lost. :hug:
April 29, 2026 — 5:00 PM
Mandy says:
Oh Chuck, I’m so so sorry. It sounds like she was the Bestest Girl. Big hugs to all of y’all.
April 29, 2026 — 5:01 PM
Jennifer Probst says:
I’m so damn sorry. But I’m also happy you shared such beautiful photos so I can know Loa and you made me cry, so that sucks, but Loa deserves it. My heart hurts for you because nothing will help for a long time, but maybe Loa deserves that too. She was so lucky to have someone who loves her that much. Sending my heartfelt apologies. My dog’s collar is still in my right hand desk drawer. I still take it out after years to just hold it and remember.
April 29, 2026 — 5:02 PM
Laura says:
weeping. understand. she’s watching over you forever.
April 29, 2026 — 5:02 PM
Jackie Pick says:
Thank you for sharing your love here. Sweet Loa is now in all of our hearts.
April 29, 2026 — 5:02 PM
benb79 says:
My condolences for Loa. I lost my Jake (8 year old Sheltie) a couple years ago. Damn. I do not have kids, but it like losing a son. Good Tasty apples to you and the family, Chuck.
April 29, 2026 — 5:03 PM
Michelle Miller says:
The loss of a beloved four legged companion hurts to like nothing else in this world. You and your family were lucky and loved, and so was Loa.
April 29, 2026 — 5:03 PM
Dove says:
Poor girl. She’ll be loved forever, but it’s never happy.
April 29, 2026 — 5:05 PM
Julia says:
So sorry. What an absolutely gorgeous tribute.
April 29, 2026 — 5:06 PM
Katie O'Donnell says:
I am so very sorry for your loss. We lost our oldest cat not very long ago, and feel similar pain to yours. Sending you lots of love and comfort and being able to remember the joyful things. This couldn’t have been a more fitting tribute to the best dog. Thank you for letting us read it.
April 29, 2026 — 5:07 PM
Richard Pulfer says:
I’m so sorry for your loss. Dogs are the best.
Losing them is the worst.
April 29, 2026 — 5:07 PM
Dawn says:
I am sobbing, sir. Thank you for sharing such a loving tribute. Not that I don’t always, everyday, but, tonight, I will hug my dog extra firmly and kiss her extra big, furry head.
April 29, 2026 — 5:07 PM
Henry Brandt says:
Love and love to you and yours.
April 29, 2026 — 5:07 PM
Destiny says:
You have my utmost sympathy in losing your sweet Loa. I have to go splash some cold water on my face now because it’s blotchy from crying.
April 29, 2026 — 5:08 PM
Deanne Fountaine says:
Thank you for sharing Loa with us. She was perfect.
April 29, 2026 — 5:08 PM
Hayden says:
Condolences, Chuck. Sorry, got some crap in my eyes over here, and can’t see the keyboard so great just now.
April 29, 2026 — 5:08 PM
jinxleah says:
I lost two of my soul kitties over the years. I have their ashes, collars and toys sitting on the highest shelf in my house so they can watch over everything. Our babies sink deep into our hearts. My deepest condolences to you.
April 29, 2026 — 5:11 PM
Robert Wack says:
Sorry for your loss, Chuck. She sounds like a wonderful, beautiful dog.
April 29, 2026 — 5:15 PM
Carrie says:
Oh, Chuck. I am so sorry. We are all richer for her existence and poorer for her loss. ❤️
April 29, 2026 — 5:16 PM
T.R. says:
So very sorry for your loss, Chuck. Like so many others, I seem to be suffering from a severe allergic reaction right now. It’s very hard to see the computer screen and the stupid keyboard. Hang in there. Sending you and your family peace, even though there’s no doubt you won’t feel it for a while.
April 29, 2026 — 5:16 PM
Lori Penza says:
I’m so very sorry to read this news. Take time to grieve and remember.
April 29, 2026 — 5:17 PM
cofax says:
I’m so sorry. They are all the best dogs.
You gave her a great life, and sent her out with as little pain as you could.
April 29, 2026 — 5:17 PM
James says:
I feel your loss so closely because it has happened to me, twice, and will happen again, twice, because after my heart grew around the grief of the first pair, I went and got a second pair. I grieve with and for you, no one ever tells you how much it’s going to hurt. Or how empty you feel. It was much harder than the deaths of each of my parents. Thank you for sharing your grief and pain. May Loa’s memory always bring a smile and a warm hug.
April 29, 2026 — 5:17 PM
Ethan August says:
Thanks so much for sharing your love of Loa with us, Chuck. You were so lucky to have each other.
It never gets easier to say goodbye to our companions. But it’s the kind of difficulty that reminds you of the heart in your chest, even if it’s because the wind is whistling through its new hole. Hope you find some harmony in grieving Loa together with your family.
April 29, 2026 — 5:17 PM
sere40 says:
Oh Loa, you probably don’t know how your time here on earth meant the world to your family. How I wish we could all live in the present like dogs do. I’ve had many dogs in my life- as many as three at one time, but one dog in particular, Daisy, I still wish would walk through my door. She was the gentlest, kindest soul I’ve ever met. Small children would come up to her and the next thing we knew they would be extending their little sloppy tongues to french kiss her. And Daisy reveled in it. She let children lead her on leash anywhere and she was ready for fun. She was also too smart for her own good- almost died by sticking her head in a plastic cereal bag to get the last cocoa-puff. Had our other dog not warned us, she would have died much sooner. She also got cancer, an insidious, too small bone kind that they couldn’t find until her leg snapped- like the sound of an elastic band, and they fitted her with a bionic metal leg. She was a super star until she couldn’t be. She’s been gone 9 years and I still cry thinking about the loss. My husband, who never grew up with dogs still gets weepy when thinking about her. He wrote this poem for me. Maybe you might like it as you and your family grieve, along with Snoobug, who will be lost without her pal.
FIVE SIMPLE WAYS TO GET OVER YOUR DOG DYING
I
Denial
Say it can never happen and mean it.
Buy that new leash, open all those new cans.
Take that picture, the one in the sun splashed
Park from last year, and have a friend do a
Painting. Make it cover a wall. And call
This work “Me And My Dog In The Park
Forever And Ever.”
When the man with the gentle face and soft
Voice administers the final sting,
It will be somewhere else, not here, not you,
Not today, and above all (please) not this dog.
II
Anger
Say it can never happen and mean it.
What do doctors know? The news is stuffed full
Of their screw-ups. And vets are just med school
Dropouts. They make mistakes. Last week I read
About a collie who was given three
Weeks and made it six years. No one really
Knows anything.
As for the appointment you made for next
Week, that day will not come. And if it must,
Then it will be somewhere else, not here, not
You, not now, above all please not this dog.
III
Bargaining
Say it can never happen and mean it.
Pray she will leap up, and run away, and
Keep running. The online guides, our soothing
Soothsayers, tell us we might secretly
Make deals with God “or some other higher
Power,” to hide from reality. But
No one ever made a deal with nothing.
If he so loved the world, then that love is
Wholly absent, not present.
Skip bargaining, and don’t speak of love
To the man with the gentle face and voice
Of sorrow. The last sting must happen. Just
Not now, and above all, please, not this dog.
IV
Fear
Say it can never happen and hold fast.
Fear is the sun, best not looked at too close.
The trick is never letting him in. When
He comes at 2AM, drunk, reminding
You of what starts your tears, block him out, think
Of those times in a tree tall summer’s day,
By the pooling creek, and it was just you,
The dog, and the kind of September-fresh
Wind that breathes all things new. Together
You watched a fall sun set behind Mount
Baker, glowing blue.
If the nice man with two needles must come,
Let your best friend know she was east and west,
Your day and your night, and no one will mind
Your saying so, because it will all be true.
V
Acceptance
In the far north the sun of spring is passing,
And tomorrow the gentlest soul I ever knew
Must pass too. Tears come quite unbidden,
Uncalled for, hot, streaking, and I can’t see.
On Monday a gentle man I know well
Will stand at the door and knock. Tenderly
He will take her in his arms and call her
Name. The second sting will end her long pain.
I just hope he’s brought a third needle, one
That can make my wife and I forget we
Are here, anywhere but here, and not now,
And please above all not this dog.
For Daisy
2002-2017
April 29, 2026 — 5:22 PM
Scott Breslove says:
Yeah, sure, thanks, I was really looking for a reason to cry today…
But in all seriousness, I never knew her, but I feel like I do now. What a good girl. You were both lucky to have found each other. Pets might not be your whole life…but they make your life whole.
April 29, 2026 — 5:23 PM
JM Celi says:
I’m so sorry, Chuck. Loa sounds amazing, and those pictures are heart-melting. Losing a dog is unbearable, and I’m so sorry for your loss.
April 29, 2026 — 5:24 PM
inaina says:
Chuck, I am so sorry. There are some animals who are just a blessing to us in every moment of time together, and Loa sounds like one of those. Again, I am so so sorry for your loss.
April 29, 2026 — 5:24 PM
multiversalbeta says:
Thank you for sharing, man. I’m really, REALLY sorry. I’ve had to say goodbye to many, MANY “Loa’s” in my own life, so I know exactly how much this fucking hurts. But it sounds like your family had a lot of amazing years with her, so hold on tight to those cherished memories. And thank you again for sharing, especially the great photos you included. I can only read this post and imagine how wonderful a pooch she truly was.
April 29, 2026 — 5:27 PM
slipperywordswriter says:
I’m so sorry, Chuck. I’m crying reading your post because she was clearly the best dog.
April 29, 2026 — 5:30 PM
Sandy Kashmar says:
Thank you for sharing this story and the beautiful photos, Chuck. I am 74, and have lost several “soul dogs” in my life. Lia sounds like the perfect friend, and I cried as I shared your family’s grief while reading, but grinned, too, as you shared the deep love and some of the wonderful moments of her presence and the immense joy she brought to you all! Bless you!
April 29, 2026 — 5:33 PM
Sandy Kashmar says:
Sorry for misspelling her name! Loa will never be forgotten!
April 29, 2026 — 5:37 PM
wdjoyner says:
May her spirit live on.
April 29, 2026 — 5:37 PM
Penny Ramirez says:
Loa was so, so beautiful. I’m sobbing over here. May your memories of loving her bring you great comfort.
April 29, 2026 — 5:39 PM
Susan M. Gourley says:
I’m so sorry. After my third good dog, I couldn’t do it again. You were so fortunate to have a beautiful red dog, and she was lucky to have you.
April 29, 2026 — 5:40 PM
Ariadne says:
Beautifully expressed, Chuck. I know the pain you’re sharing. We share our lives with our furry companions, and ache when they suffer disease and old age. But also we remember the joy they brought into our lives. Your shelter puppy thrived under your loving kindness and returned it ten-fold. Having animals in our lives enriches us and makes a needed connection with life. And that pain we feel when they depart is the joy/cost of love.
April 29, 2026 — 5:40 PM
Beth Hanson says:
10 years ago we lost Peanut, the best cat in the world, a shelter cat that was always patient with my kids and watched over them while they were outside. I have tears going down my face because I understand there are exceptional pets that come into your life at just the right time. It is our privilege to have them in our lives.
April 29, 2026 — 5:42 PM
Nicholas Brandt says:
Thank you for sharing her story. Loa sounds like the best dog. And the pictures are there to prove it. My heart goes out to you and your family.
April 29, 2026 — 5:45 PM
Nathalie Samson says:
So very sorry for the passing of The Inimitable LOA.
We are all fundamentally changed by the loss of our “best” dogs, and the magic is that we come through the pain of this loss, better people for having been owned by them.
Its clear to me, by your account, that LOA wielded such magic.
April 29, 2026 — 5:48 PM
soulpatch59 says:
I am so sorry for your loss; I have been there. I grieve for Loa with you today. A very beautiful girl. May her memory be a blessing.
April 29, 2026 — 5:50 PM
Linda Jeffers says:
You gave Loa an amazing life. Fuck dog cancer.
April 29, 2026 — 5:51 PM
Amy Drees says:
Rest easy, Loa. No dog ever lives long enough.
April 29, 2026 — 5:53 PM
amandahoving says:
This was beautifully written. Even a cat lover (should there be any present) would agree. So very sorry.
April 29, 2026 — 5:53 PM
Chris says:
Thinking of all of you today, Chuck. Thank you for writing this, so we can ugly cry together and hopefully carry some of your sadness, in exchange for the joy of Loa that you shared with us. Wishing you all peace.
April 29, 2026 — 5:55 PM
John Boggs says:
Oh, your sweet, poor girl. My heart goes out to you and the rest of your family. We lost our Norman 3 years ago and I still can’t bring myself to bring another dog home; I hope that others understanding your grief is in some respect a comfort.
April 29, 2026 — 5:55 PM
innerspacegirl says:
the existence of dogs is probably the only thing that could convince me of the otherwise remote possibility that god(s) is(are) real. dogs are, indeed, all the best. being around them is treasure in three dimensions. I feel your loss.
April 29, 2026 — 5:59 PM
Kristin Dearborn says:
I’m having a little cry over here for sweet Loa. That’s a beautiful eulogy for the best dog. (I maintain that every dog is the best dog in his or her own unique way.) Love and pets to Snoobug, and I’m sure thinking of you and your family ❤️
April 29, 2026 — 6:02 PM
Jane Jensen says:
I am so sorry. We never have enough time with our fur family. 10 years on, I still miss my soul dog. A true gentleman towards dogs and humans alike. A bit more human than most humans and I always believed he knew way more than he was letting on. When it worked in his favor he made it clear he understood exactly what I was saying. He would not poop if I was looking at him….”a little privacy please”. A gentle soul he would move from patient to patient in the Alzheimer day care center and sometimes they would speak for the first time in weeks. A once in a lifetime dog. I am sorry. Eventually the smiles and stories will come before the sadness, but they will always be the one and only best dog. Really.
April 29, 2026 — 6:06 PM
Jacey Bedford says:
Losing them is the price we pay for having them in our lives for a time. We lost our very good girl about 16 months ago and miss her every day.
April 29, 2026 — 6:09 PM