There are bluebirds in our apple tree this morning and I am sad for them. Sad for the tree, too. The tree is a crabapple tree, technically. It’s an old tree, bursting with fruit. The tree doesn’t know who won or lost an election or what an election is. The birds don’t know, either, and I’m happy they get to have that. We also haven’t had meaningful, measurable rain in five, six weeks now. We’ve wildfires popping up just a few miles away. It’s November 6th and will be 80 degrees today. The tree and the birds must know they’re thirsty. They will know if fire comes for them.
I’m sure the rain will come, and I’m hopeful we will be untouched by fire, but I also know the lack of rain will dry us out more often, just as I know it’ll flood more often, and I know the fires will come more often, and the tornadoes, too. And you like to hope that someone in charge has a plan, that they believe in this reality going on around us, that they share in the same reality we do. But we’re not there anymore. We lost that yesterday. We lost a lot yesterday. (Perhaps chief among them the illusion that we shared one country, or even one collective reality.) I don’t know why or how we lost it, precisely. We can unpack it however we want to — the mainstream media sanewashed the man; the woman was a woman and men would rather choose to control women than vote for them; don’t forget the racism, can’t forget the racism; the woman ran the wrong campaign and cozied up to the GOP and didn’t say enough about Gaza and global warming; it was the economy, stupid; it’s Russia; it’s disinformation and misinformation and Musk and RFK and the price of milk and the cost of rent and something about the border and something about COVID and —
What I know is that I don’t know. What I know is the things I thought I knew, or that I believed were true, really aren’t, and that once more I exist in need of a word, perhaps a German one, that expresses both the act of being shocked and a total lack of shock at the exact same time.
I knew he could win. I half-expected it. And yet all parts of me strained against the illogic of it, the sheer incredulity of the possibility of his win. People looked at his first four years, at COVID, at January 6th, at all his promises, his crimes, at all his people, at all the ones who told us he was a fascist, a dictator, an anti-democratic nightmare, and they said, “Yeah, him again, let’s fucking go.” And they pressed the self-destruct button, using the system of democracy to attempt to undo the system of democracy.
People chose this. In considerable number. This, grotesquely, is democracy in action. Though a democracy mauled into a cruder shape by disinformation.
This is a doom post. I don’t want it to be (and I’m sorry for it) but I also don’t want to be flippant or twee. I don’t want to hashtag-resist you into trying to have hope on a dark day. Perhaps some dark days must simply be dark and we must be in that darkness. Maybe we need to let people have their hopelessness today. Let them have their doom. Do not scold. Give them no stirring platitudes nor poetry of resistance. Just let people sit and ruminate however they must on the hard mad road ahead.
Because that road ahead is hard, and it will be maddening. We’re in some very serious trouble. The climate, the environment, those bluebirds and that tree, are at stake here. Our friends — especially transgender folks, cisgender women, really anybody who isn’t a straight white Christian dude with money — is going to be worse for wear at some point soon, even if they voted for him. It’ll be up to us to help them, to protect our friends, even when we don’t know how, even when we may need that protection ourselves.
Our democracy is in danger — all the lights on the console are blinking red, and the klaxons are deafening. Is there a deportation force coming? Are we really going to ban vaccines? Are we going to put Musk and RFK Jr. in charge of important levers and buttons? How deeply will we cement a corroded, cruel SCOTUS majority and for how long, and will we even be able to turn the tables on that again? I don’t know. It really isn’t good. A lot was on the line yesterday and while I like to think we, as the at-this-point-cringey-cliche goes, left it all on the field. The stakes were high and we lost. And there may be a lot of suffering in the wake of that.
This isn’t a post with a plan, this isn’t a pep talk, this isn’t about hope. I’m wallowing in the doom for a moment. Maybe it’s foolish. Maybe I shouldn’t be doing that, or telling you about it. But I wanted to say it, to be true to where my head and my heart are at. I want it to be okay to feel shitty. To not force joy. I don’t want some artifice of hope. To be a lantern in this tunnel right now feels false. I feel like I need to be in the darkness here, to be one with it, to become part of this new, lightless reality. I’ll get there. I’ll get back to a better place. But right now I want to realize how much trouble we’re in before I tell you how we deal with it. Maybe the worry and the fear will motivate me. I don’t know. I’m sitting with it. I’m considering the trouble, the doom, the darkness. I’m thinking about the bluebirds and the crabapple tree. And I’m hoping somewhere in the darkness I find a way forward.
If you need it, there’s 988 Lifeline — call or chat.
And the trans lifeline, too, here.
Paul weimer says:
Indeed. All I can do is plod forward, but I feel like I am plodding into the darkness, never to return.
November 6, 2024 — 9:10 AM
scottsemegran says:
I’m with you. Sadness doesn’t quite cover it.
November 6, 2024 — 9:15 AM
Patrick Raring says:
Never would I think that the Dark Side would win (Fear leads to Anger. Anger leads to Hate. Hate leads to Suffering.). I thought for sure more than half of the country would choose positivity, common sense, kindness, and hope.
November 6, 2024 — 9:17 AM
Doug Daniel says:
The results are still coming in, but I am willing to bet that more than half did. Remember, the electoral college is a kink in the straight democratic process we wish we had.
November 6, 2024 — 9:21 AM
taosmoxie says:
She lost by 1.5% of the popular vote. Yet he claims a “mandate” – he’s already started. Now I’m off to finish my novel. Art matters in times like these (as we learned in round one).
November 6, 2024 — 9:28 AM
Doug Daniel says:
Thank you for the correction. What I get for flapping my gums before checking the numbers.
November 6, 2024 — 9:40 AM
Jennifer Bolin says:
Thank you, Chuck. I needed to acknowledge the doom. I will sit with mine too. My quiet doom.
November 6, 2024 — 9:17 AM
Doug Daniel says:
Thanks for this. You encapsulated my feelings perfectly, far better than I could have expressed it at the moment. The plain fact of the matter is that we are in for a time of trial and trouble. It’s impossible right now to see what is on the other side, or how far we have to go to get there.
November 6, 2024 — 9:19 AM
Book Hogs says:
Completely devastated.
November 6, 2024 — 9:22 AM
Linda McCann Jeffers says:
My kids (recent college grad and college senior) are making plans to leave this country. They asked me to explore dual citizenship possibilities for them. They don’t want to stay and do the work to fix this mess we created, and who can blame them. If they leave and I have the excuse to leave to “be with them” I may just take it. I’m exhausted and I’m pretty privileged. I can’t imagine what this is like for some people.
November 6, 2024 — 9:24 AM
John Harding says:
Yeah. Similar situation for me too. I’m so tired of this BS and I wonder if I’ll just give up and leave…
November 6, 2024 — 10:15 AM
Jacey Bedford says:
And presuming there’s anything left of the world in 2028, there’s JD Vance waiting in the wings. Looking at it from my side of the Atlantic, it doesn’t look good (big understatement). I want my family back home (from VA) before the brown stuff hits the whirly thing, but there’s not much chance of that, jobs being what they are. The Orange Criminal scares me shitless, and he’s not even MY president. The lunatics are truly in charge of the asylum. My condolences, America.
November 6, 2024 — 9:24 AM
taosmoxie says:
Thank you for reading my broken heart, mind, and spirit. We WILL find a way forward through this darkness. We must.
November 6, 2024 — 9:25 AM
Melinda says:
i
November 6, 2024 — 9:27 AM
Melinda says:
Well, let’s try that again. Yes, I am not doing well this morning, assuming I could actually have an idea what to do.
I practice Soto Zen. I don’t think I can even Zen my way forward right now.
November 6, 2024 — 9:29 AM
Heidi Wilson says:
I didn’t even make it till my meditation timer went off this morning. Try again this afternoon….
November 6, 2024 — 9:40 AM
Lancelot says:
logischeverwirrung — a logical confusion
geschocktnichtgeschockt — shocked and unshocked
best I got right now.
November 6, 2024 — 9:31 AM
Kara says:
Feels weird to say thank you for a doom post, but thank you.
November 6, 2024 — 9:35 AM
Heidi Wilson says:
Set up a recurring donation to the ACLU this morning. You’ll feel better. I did.
November 6, 2024 — 9:39 AM
Rebecca Douglass says:
Did that a couple of years ago. And the Union of Concerned Scientists.
November 6, 2024 — 11:10 AM
Tom Witherspoon says:
I went to bed around Midnight. My partner joined me three hours later. “He won,” she wept as she crawled into bed beside me. I held her and we both wept and promised to love each other and be there for one another and that no matter what we would not give into the darkness. We drifted off to sleep.
I awoke two hours later. She was breathing softly, sleeping. I got up, and wrote 880 more words for my WIP.
I have always been a glass-half-full kinda guy. I always light a candle against the darkness. But, you need the darkness in order for the candle light to shine. I hope that my light, however meager, lights someone’s way.
I will go on. I will grieve. I will go on. I will grieve. I will go on.
November 6, 2024 — 9:39 AM
Courtney Cantrell says:
I think it’s okay to just feel shitty and wallow today. And for the coming days. Maybe not for *weeks*, because that amount of gloom tips us over into something more insidious that looks an awful lot like resignation. But for now, yes: we do get to heartbroken and scared and desperately sad. And, as Spider Robinson says, the more we share our pain with each other, the more we’ll be able to bear it.
November 6, 2024 — 9:41 AM
Ruth Nestvold says:
There’s also “Erschütterung” – complete shock. But what I’m mostly feeling right now is “Freudlosigkeit” – lack of joy. Close to lack of anything. I kind of expected it, but I still can’t believe.
So I’m going to go wallow in my Freudlosigkeit now …
November 6, 2024 — 9:42 AM
Lynn Foss says:
I feel like we are so doomed. It’s hard to see forward or even see anything ahead that’s good. Having said that it’s going sound weird when I thank you for this. Maybe we can inch forward to find something good and worthy. I will hope that your bluebird and crab apple tree will gather the strength to fight for out collective futures. Thank you, again.
November 6, 2024 — 9:53 AM
S. Edwards says:
I was on the phone at 4:30 am with my trans niece, who is terrified, trying to face this. I think it’s okay to take the day, to just be angry or afraid or what the fuck. Take the day. I told her, we’ll take 72hrs, listen hard. I don’t know what comes next, but for today, I’m taking the day. Here’s to the bluebirds and the crabapples and the promise of rain.
November 6, 2024 — 9:55 AM
Clark Carlton says:
Deep thanks, Chuck. You are right that now is not the time for a pep talk, it’s a time to grieve. Nor is it a time for talking about leaving the U.S.A. for Canada or elsewhere. Trump’s presidency is likely to pass the baton to China as the dominant superpower and it will also strengthen the rise of an imperial Russia. We may become like those two autocratic nations and be a democracy in name only. The Billionaire Boys Club is succeeding in controlling the world. Trump is their puppet and the real president is Elon Musk. And as you rightly point out, the real casualty in this election is our one and only Earth being ravaged by climate change.
Grieve now then fight like hell.
November 6, 2024 — 9:56 AM
MaryAnn Lockard says:
Thank you, Chuck
November 6, 2024 — 9:57 AM
M. Oniker says:
Thank you for writing what I couldn’t. I’ve thought all of that. I’ve been crying off/on all day. Americans voted democratically to end democracy, wtf? Over 70 million? I’ve lost all words.
November 6, 2024 — 10:03 AM
Will Humphreys says:
I’m with you. Thanks for expressing this
November 6, 2024 — 10:11 AM
John Harding says:
Thanks. I’m crying here
November 6, 2024 — 10:12 AM
Tanya Stewart says:
I’m sitting here before the screen, shelllshocked that a humanoid so ugly, so horribly flawed, could have been reelected to the highest office in this country, and by how many people for what qualities? Both parties made their candidate choices not by how well they could represent the people, but by how well they pandered to the corporations. We, the People—all of us who just want to breathe deeply and live the lives we choose—don’t deserve this unending horror.
November 6, 2024 — 10:26 AM
Heather says:
Goodbye women’s rights, goodbye public health, goodbye freedom of the press. Goodbye environment. I couldn’t watch results last night. I just knew it was going to be bad. I woke up actually feeling nauseated and I hadn’t even checked to confirm the results yet. It’s worse this time because there is no one who will be willing to stop him. He’s got his panel is sycophants and ass kissers ready to wreak chaos. All for the joy of watching it happen. Why do insecure white men keep winning. Why can’t enough people stand up to the bullshit and stop it.
November 6, 2024 — 11:10 AM
Heather says:
Whoops I meant to post this as a general reply and didn’t mean to post it as a response to yours. Sorry
November 6, 2024 — 11:14 AM
Natasha Peterson says:
Thanks for writing. I’m with the bluebirds. He won by only 1.5% of the popular vote. Maybe think about staying engaged as a constituent. Maybe continue to call and email your representatives nay and yay which, believe it or not, makes a difference on The Hill — the notion of measured public intolerance and opinion.
November 6, 2024 — 11:02 AM
Kristi Belcamino says:
Thank you for this
November 6, 2024 — 11:21 AM