It’s difficult to see how he wins, if we’re being honest. That is to say, if we’re also being logical. But we do not live in an honest age. Or a logical one.
Still — reality has stacked itself against him. The pattern isn’t good, though patterns do not always hold true, and few of them are forever. Just the same, increased voter turnout has yet so far not rewarded Republicans very much, and this cycle we are definitely seeing increased turnout. Polling, which already slightly seems to favor her, also has been wonkier and wonkier with each cycle, largely undercounting Democratic momentum. And each cycle since 2016 has more or less been a repudiation of the man, a turn away from him and many of his chosen acolytes. His own staff of the past doesn’t support him. He’s a felon. He’s suffering some manner of cognitive decline, where a brain that was once made of pudding is now made of old pudding, pudding that gets that gross chitinous skin on top of it, pudding that starts to leak its own brown deliquescence out onto the countertop. He’s old. He’s hateful. He brings little joy and mostly — well, it’s not even anger, it’s not even wrath, not precisely. It’s grievances. A thousand petty grievances, leaking from his pores, from his pale lips, from his puckered butthole eyes. Denethor with the tomato. As for her — a campaign that was relegated to feeling like two old sacks of white guy slugging it out turned into a thing of hope and delight and potential, even if that potential is complicated by the crass realities of politics. She’s got energy. She’s got momentum. She’s got bigger fucking rallies, and if the size matters, then she’s got size on lock.
Were you to dangle me over a pit of crocodiles and demand I pick who I thought would win this horrible contest on Tuesday, a contest between a savvy, capable woman and a bigoted inside-out Halloween mask, I’d say I think she’s going to win. Not just because I want her to. But because that’s just how it looks from here.
But looks can be deceiving.
And he can very much win.
He can win because we may not clearly see the deeply sunken groundswell of hate that refuses to report on itself, that will soon burst forth like an infection. He can win if there are enough aggrieved young men, mostly white, but not all, each taught that things aren’t working out for them because They, with the conspiratorial capital T, are viciously working against them from the shadows, from the borders, from the gender-neutral bathrooms. He can win because, simply put, there are horrible people who like him, who like that he’s horrible. He can win because some of them have been hiding in plain sight. Look no further than that neighbor who you liked very much, who you thought was normal, who one morning went out and stuck one of his fucking signs on their lawn. He can win because logic and honesty do not always win the day. He can win with racism and sexism. He can win because we live in the upside-down and chaos definitely reigns.
And I think it’s important to realize that if he wins, which he can —
We are pretty fucked.
I do not want to be a huge bummer — after all, it’s Wednesday, it’s Hump Day, we’re over the hump, we do some humping, whatever, I dunno what it even means — but we are very seriously in super-fucked territory if he wins.
Which he can.
I am tired, of course, of existential elections — and sure, all elections, big and small, are important in ways that are obvious and in ways that are not, but very few of them feel quite like an apocalyptic hinge. Where if the door swings one way, we all get to leave and go out and play in the sun — but if it swings the other way, the lock clicks and we’re trapped in a house on fire.
If he wins, climate change — already at a tipping point — falls off the agenda, and shit definitely tips in the other direction, probably for good.
If he wins, bigotry wins, too — our trans friends are in trouble, our migrant friends are in trouble, women are in trouble. They’re already targets in this life, but now the bullseyes get a whole lot bigger. They’ll suffer.
If he wins, abortion rights are gone, gone, gone. Women will die in numbers far greater than they do now. IVF, also gone. Birth control, gone. Not right away. But the front sights are set. They’re targets. We’re targets.
If he wins, Elon Musk will be in charge of the economy, which is like — well, how do you quantify that with a metaphor? He’s already the best worst example. He bought Twitter, fucked its rock-solid branding, then drove it off a cliff into a swamp. The Cybertruck is easily the most embarrassing American product released, and that’s in a country where we have Shake Weights and hats that say FBI FEDERAL BOOB INSPECTOR. Musk wants to cut all “non-essential” spending, which is to say, he wants to set fire to the American economy, either because he’s a skipping dipshit or because he knows if he crashes the car they can sell the scrap metal to Russia.
If he wins, RFK Jr. will be in charge of health policy, which is like — well, it’s like if you let Elon Musk run the economy. They want vaccine mandates in schools gone. Vaccines. Vaccines. Easily one of the most crucial victories for civilization, they want to kick to the curb. We’ll all be licking roadkill and sharing brainworms. Elon Musk’s mind-chips will have a little glass terrarium for RFK Jr.’s brainworms. A match made in hell.
If he wins, democracy is skewered. That’s not my promise. It’s his. And he has a Supreme Court who has confirmed that he has a truly alarming freedom from consequences. Worse, he’ll get to pick more justices, potentially.
If he wins, it’ll be another four years — and maybe more — where we wake up every day, every fucking day, and the moment we glance at the news we know we’re going to be inundated with some new stupid shitty thing he said or did or both, some racist shit, some sexist shit, some ignorant shit, one more thing broken and left on the floor in shards. Guardrails kicked over, systems dismantled, safety nets sliced into ribbons. Every day, every goddamn day we’ll have to joylessly wake up and bear witness to the great dismantling.
If he wins, Russia wins. Ukraine is in deep. And Netanyahu wins, too, and Palestine ends up as beachfront property, with blood soaking the sand.
If he wins, billionaires and corporations get more rights than we do, and our already-termite-chewed regulatory state will collapse into sawdust. Lead in our toys, listeria in our food, planes breaking in half, every car an 8-bit dumpster. What brittle trust we have now, stepped on like a cookie, turned into a scattering of crumbs.
If he wins, the next pandemic — bird flu, if I had to put money on it, though in this hell-age it’ll probably be aerosolized gonorrhea or a zombie plague– is gonna get us real good. It’ll be worse, somehow, than the last one. What, you think RFK, Jr. is going to fix it? We’ll all have to line up at our chiropractor to get our daily ivermectin shots as we cough and puke and boil.
If he wins, information will mean nothing. Misinformation and disinformation will be the best we get. A hurricane of bullshit.
If he wins, AI will be absolutely everywhere.
If he wins, truth will be absolutely nowhere.
If he wins, the rich get richer, and the rest get fucked.
If he wins…
It’ll all come crashing down.
All of it.
Everything. And though some may romanticize this as some essential breaking of a corrupt and corroded cycle, the romantasy of it dies under the pile of wreckage and the heaps of actual dead people.
And the thing is, what I’ve mentioned here, it’s just the tip of the iceberg. Haven’t talked about education, or surveillance, or book bans, or holy fuck, how he has threatened to use the military on the “enemies from within,” enemies he has identified as being his political opponents.
It’ll be a nightmare, unfolding slow, then fast, where we get front row seats watching a dystopia form to carry us through an apocalypse.
But we have another way.
You gotta vote, and you gotta vote Harris / Walz. You gotta help others do the same. And I know, there are certainly policies you don’t agree with of hers, and here I encourage you to watch Bernie Sanders on that point. It’s good to have principles, but not when the execution of those principles serves only your moral comfort and not, say, the greater good. The perfect cannot be the enemy of that good. We choose the path that gets us collectively closer to a better place — not the path that will take us into only darkness.
If you’re like me, you’re currently gnawing yourself down to the nerve bundles. You know how when you have an appointment at 3PM, you have a hard time accomplishing anyfuckingthing until 3PM? The election is like that 3PM appointment for me. Mostly I’m just sitting here, staring forward, trying to accomplish something but mostly only rawdogging reality like it’s a bumpy overseas flight. But there are things you can do.
You can phonebank, knock on doors, and you can also call folks who have already voted to help cure problematic ballots. Talk to your friends, your relatives, talk to people online. Help them do what has to be done.
Let’s do this.
Let’s get it done.
Let’s never go back to him. Because if he wins —
Nah. Let’s just not let him win, okay? Right? Right.
LFG.
Jen Doktorski says:
Brilliantly summarized. Agreed on all points.
October 30, 2024 — 10:56 AM
Simone Cortes says:
Brilliant! Thank you.
October 30, 2024 — 11:08 AM
Lancelot says:
I want to say for those who have never canvassed before: it’s really easy. And people are WAY kinder in person than online and therefore more persuadable. The campaign will walk you through it and you won’t be alone.
People bussing from Brooklyn and elsewhere. Try it with some friends
October 30, 2024 — 11:10 AM
David Corbett says:
Absolutely. My experience has been overwhelmingly positive.
October 30, 2024 — 11:32 AM
Laramie Louis Bahr says:
Well said, Mr. Wendig. Chuck. Can I call you Chuck? He’s a cesspool in a meaty bag of fat with the IQ of a curtain rod. How anyone who is poor, middle class, non-white, female, struggling to make ends meet, and/or semi-lucid can honestly believe he has their best interests at heart is completely beyond me. I left the country the last time we let hate win. We simply cannot be that collectively naive again.
October 30, 2024 — 11:13 AM
Heather says:
This is everything I’m thinking. We either have a hopeful future or dystopian dreams come to fruition. Let hope win.
October 30, 2024 — 11:13 AM
Jemima Pett says:
Good luck. Here in the UK we were hoping for change, and got the sensible outcome. For the sake of the world, we hope you do too.
October 30, 2024 — 11:23 AM
Cal "Stretch" Armstrong says:
Based on what I see online from your fellow Brits, I am not sure that is the case for you.
October 30, 2024 — 1:56 PM
Rebecca Douglass says:
Excellently well put. I have a trans daughter and a Venuzuelan daughter-in-law. My angst about this election is off the charts. We all live in states where the electoral college votes are a lock, but I’ve been doing what I can.
October 30, 2024 — 11:24 AM
Jenn says:
Afuckingmen, Chuck.
October 30, 2024 — 11:26 AM
David Corbett says:
As the spouse of a Norwegian citizen, it would be nice to believe that we have an escape route. But right now, Norway is seeing the kind of probing operations in the far north near the Barents Sea (where Russia has its nuclear sub base), seeing how far they can push before there’s any significant pushback. It’s not just us who will be surely fucked. We are at a pivot point as a civilization. Scared people want “strength,” which too often means they want a daddy–in this case a pudgy, aggrieved, whiny, incompetent, pudding-brained (brilliant metaphor) loser–instead of a competent former prosecutor, because, you know (dot dot dot). I’ve been canvassing for the local Dems and I’ve been encouraged by the enthusiasm and sense of urgency. But I live in NY (the Hudson Valley, which currently has a GOP rep) and it’s hard to know what will happen elsewhere. Regardless, as we’ve seen with the ascension of Vance, the MAGA movement will not wither away no matter what happens next Tuesday. We have to gear up for a long fight. Okay then. Thanks for the pep talk, Chuck.
October 30, 2024 — 11:31 AM
TCinLA says:
For anyone who thinks things re going to be resolved next week, I’d like to have some of whatever it is they’re smoking or dropping. It’s going to take winning at least four more presidential election as well as the congressional off-year elections, to knock the MAGA out of them. We have to win every one of those; they only have to win once.
October 30, 2024 — 4:03 PM
Debi Gliori says:
Sending waves of hope across the shining sea. May good prevail.
October 30, 2024 — 11:37 AM
Rachelle says:
Thank you for your eloquent, 100% apt description of what our country is currently experiencing. We’ve all got to fight like hell to defeat this delusional demagogue who scares the bejesus out of me and so many others. As Debi Gliori says in her comment, “May good prevail.” May it ever be so.
October 30, 2024 — 11:49 AM
Linda says:
Thank you for this. It is the first time in my long life that I truly fear we may go the way of WWII Germany. Perhaps we could just skip to the end and have him take himself out now! Sorry…I’m just so angry and frightened. Voting has very serious consequences…and it might be our last chance to cast our ballots in this country.
I wish I had your way with words!
October 30, 2024 — 11:50 AM
Barry W Finn says:
What you said sir. Exactly. Well said indeed and thank you for saying it. I’m a Canadian and I wish I could vote! We, most of us in Canada, share your fears. Harris/Walz all the way.
October 30, 2024 — 11:59 AM
Jen J. Danna says:
Amen from a fellow Canadian who is also watching this election with apprehension as the result will affect the entire planet. #HarrisWalz2024
October 30, 2024 — 2:38 PM
AJ says:
As a non-binary person leaning trans masc, I’m utterly terrified. I am identifiably LGBTQ+ by sight, so I already have a target on me. Even though I live in one of the bluest states in the whole country, I live in fear because of this orange pestilence superspreader. This whole thing has paralyzed me from the beginning, and my mental health (something they don’t even believe in) is hanging by a gossamer strand. The deep vein of hatred he’s unearthed in this country has made me question everything about people’s understanding of “freedom.”
I don’t have the capacity to be an activist, to call, to canvass, to do more than cast my own vote (which I’ve done, blue all the way through). I’m honestly rocking in a corner sucking my thumb and winding hair around my fingers.
I don’t even know the point of this comment except to say thank you for this post, so people like me can feel less alone, and that there’s hope there will potentially be enough numbers to stomp out this threat.
I’m with her.
October 30, 2024 — 12:00 PM
Donna Mugavero says:
I “liked” this but I don’t like it at all. I mean, I LOVE how you say what you say and why you say it, but I feel like an exposed nerve ending. Thank you for all you do, Chuck.
October 30, 2024 — 12:17 PM
Bridget Impey says:
You are wonderful. Thank you from Johannesburg and the bottom of our hearts. We wish we could do something from here other than refreshing the news.
October 30, 2024 — 12:22 PM
Ina says:
Thanks for saying the scary parts — I needed to hear someone else feeling as scared as I do
October 30, 2024 — 12:40 PM
Tracey says:
I haven’t been able to sleep without medicating for weeks now, because my brain keeps running through all the “if he wins” scenarios. I am absolutely terrified and 90%positive that he will win, because some people will refuse to elect a woman, some people think that “left wing liberal news” is hogwash, and some people are just hateful racist misogynistic asshats – but mostly because we are living through some Orwellian nightmare where people refuse to believe what they see or hear.
October 30, 2024 — 12:47 PM
Fatman says:
“He brings little joy and mostly — well, it’s not even anger, it’s not even wrath, not precisely. It’s grievances. A thousand petty grievances, leaking from his pores, from his pale lips, from his puckered butthole eyes. ”
This is what worries me the most, because grievance plays such a massive part in our social discourse these days.
Trump is running on zero coherent policy proposals, leaning heavily on the politics of envy. Every sentence he and his surrogates utter is steeped in garbled, unfocused wrath toward “the elites” – and parroted predominantly by folks who tried and failed to become part of said “elites”.
Angry losers are mass-rallying behind him, and angry losers have an excellent track record of swinging elections toward their preferred candidate. I hope I’m wrong, but I look over the pond at Europe, and despair.
October 30, 2024 — 12:53 PM
Kathleen Moran says:
Excellent sum-up. LFG
October 30, 2024 — 12:57 PM
Rachel says:
Thank you, Chuck. I’m forwarding your email to anyone I know who hasn’t voted yet. I live in Georgia where those kind, thoughtful neighbors are planting Trump signs in their yard. All the while I’m preparing a getaway plan for my college kid who is clearly LGBTQ+. So while they carelessly vote for a dictator, I’m wrapping my head around saying goodbye to my firstborn. Everyday, tears and worries and anxiety. It helps a little to read that others feel the same. I’m embracing you all right now. LFG
October 30, 2024 — 1:50 PM
Michelann says:
All of this. I’m going to have to flee the country if he wins. Not good. Vote blue.
October 30, 2024 — 12:57 PM
Maryann says:
I hesitate to write, and I don’t even know yet if I will press send in the end.
Background: I live in Canada, left the US in the early 70’s partly because New York City was a terrifying, dangerous mess and Montreal offered urban beauty and refuge. But a huge part was to escape my family., my tribe. With few examples, they were, and remain, rabid right wingers. Paradoxically, they were some of the most materially generous people I would ever know. But the rage? It was almost an orgasm for them.
With the passage of time, I think I’ve come to understand where all that rage came from, but which they were (male and female) unable to aim the barrels at the source.
All were almost always beaten quite badly by their parents (I can still hear my brother’s screams) and humiliated (I can still hear him cry). The ones who got off lightly were simply ignored and neglected.
It would be easy to loathe that generation. But my own father slept wearing roller skates so that when his drunken father came to beat him, he could glide away. My mother went to Mass as a little girl with bruises on her face that puzzled her Sunday morning sober mother.
Loving parental understanding and encouragement was doled out lavishly to middle-class kids, or if not, to education-rich, money-poor parents.
So they grew up to envy and hate and be scared. And hate that they were so scared. My tribe’s story is, I suspect, a common one. They want someone, anyone, to make it right. To punish someone else. I am constantly shocked at family funerals by the weeping and sobbing over the deceased who treated them like shit all their lives.
I doubt that Vance came from the sweet, loving hillbillies he describes. I’d bet the rent the shit was kicked out of him more times than he remembers. If he remembers at all.
Many think this is a lower class white male’s problem. There may be a lot of them in Trump’s fan base, but not all. We have a good friend who came from Trinidad. He’s brown, gay, grew up poor but became educated. Put put a couple of drinks in Martin and he will reveal how much he loathes privileged white progressives who have always pitied him. He wishes he could vote for Trump.
Long before Trump scooped them up and made them feel better (kind of like a shot of meth might), lower class people could smell exclusion and progressive fear and pity.
Who do you blame? I haven’t a clue. What do you do? Still haven’t a clue. The only thing I do sense is maybe, just maybe, understanding may be a start. Not excusing, not even forgiving, just trying to get to an answer. But maybe because that real understanding was not attempted for so long, we are where we are.
October 30, 2024 — 1:18 PM
Leslie A. Aguillard says:
We voted. though we hear ballot collection boxes have been set on fire. We voted and we encouraged others to vote and we’re really scared about the fascists winning or raising hell if they don’t. I sure hope you have a gazillion fans and they vote Harris.
October 30, 2024 — 1:43 PM
Cal "Stretch" Armstrong says:
I voted for Harris, and I literally vomited once I got back from dropping off my ballot. I have never voted for Dems or GOP before and this the ABSOLUTE ONLY TIME I will ever do it. I went against my instincts, interests and desire for a viable third party.
I hope I don’t regret it.
This is a one-time thing, thankfully. I will NEVER vote for a Republicrat again.
October 30, 2024 — 1:59 PM
TCinLA says:
The last viable third party was the GOP, 170 years ago. Every third party since has been a vote for what you don’t want to win.
October 30, 2024 — 4:07 PM
Fatman says:
There are no viable third parties. Only grifters seeking to exploit pockets of dissatisfaction. This time round, they’re not even pretending otherwise, but openly advertising it.
October 30, 2024 — 4:18 PM
Elizabeth says:
Yes!
October 30, 2024 — 2:39 PM
Kathy says:
Brilliant piece. Please please do what you can. Your friends from Europe.
K
October 30, 2024 — 2:56 PM
TCinLA says:
Friends who have done it tell me it’s easy to get a Portuguese residency visa and the place is both nice and not expensive. Just sayin…
October 30, 2024 — 3:59 PM