I received an email from, erm, a reader —
I’m quoting the email in its entirety but stripping out a few identifying bits.
Be warned: this email is a real journey.
“And now you’re – you’re like any other piece-of-shit god-complex dickhead who got too full of himself to see the people around him as people.”
That is exactly how I thought of you when I finished Black River Orchard. Similar to Hillary calling people deplorables and suggesting they need to be deprogrammed as if they are cult members. The constant berating of people who don’t think like you was nauseating. I don’t think you could make your feelings about anyone outside of your political beliefs any more clear. You don’t see them as people, just your political enemy.
I was looking forward to reading this book as I love horror, but the only horror was how elitist you came across. Good for you, you’re sooooo progressive because you mentioned trans, ENBY, a lesbian couple, sex dungeon, BDSM, bigots, stolen land, religious nuts, and non-vaxers? My daughter and I have books that come with trigger warnings about monster cocks, so you’re not special.
Although I’m not a Trump-thumping Republican, I feel you would look down on me and not see me as a person because I’m rural and not educated enough to be impressed with all your keywords. My husband works in [REDACTED] and I work for a [REDACTED]. On a positive note, I also work in a fabulous [REDACTED] where I can find other works that are truly horror. I did enjoy the history lesson about apples. I happen to like Honeycrisp apples, especially from a semi-local orchard.
email from, obviously, a huge fan
I have not responded to this person, as yet, and likely won’t. I’m not sure what she hoped to achieve by writing this email, though I almost wish she’d write it as an actual review because, wow. Yeah.
The email did come in through the contact form on this website, so if the person who wrote this email is here, well, hi. Sorry I didn’t include more monster cocks in my book? I guess? I hope you and your daughter find all the wonderful apolitical monster cock books your hearts desire, but I come from a world where everyone gets their very own Sex Dungeon.
Or something.
Anyway, this is your reminder that all art is political and who gets to write the art and who is included in the art and who gets mad at the art — that’s all part of the politics of a piece. Like it or not. Thinking you can keep politics out of art is like thinking you can keep a fish alive out of water. It has to swim there even when it doesn’t realize it’s swimming there. Just because the fish doesn’t know what water is doesn’t mean the water doesn’t exist.
ANYWAY.
I casually appear in your mind to whisper, “Hey, I’m going out on the second leg of my book tour this week,” which means I’m gonna be at the following places on the following dates:
Friday, October 13th, 6:00 PM
Denver, CO
Tattered Cover Bookstore
Details here! Order from the store.
—
Sunday, October 15th, 4:00 PM
Helena, MT
Montana Book Company
Details here! Order from the store.
—
Monday, October 16th, 7:00PM
Portland, OR
Powells Bookstore, Cedar Crossing location
Event details here! Preorder from the store.
—
Wednesday, October 18th, 7:00PM
Seattle, WA
Elliott Bay Books
* In conversation with Sadie Hartmann
Event details here! Preorder from the store.
Also, there are some new Black River Orchard reviews out there:
Paste Magazine: “As with his previous horror novel, the towering Book of Accidents, Wendig lays out a beautifully structured narrative web of multiple points-of-view, time periods, and story threads, weaving a tapestry through inviting prose and memorable characters in which readers will get happily lost. In a narrative that spans 600 pages, Wendig builds a series of deeply personal stakes for a lineup of people who are all caught in the strange shadows of Harrow’s past, then shows us how they intertwine, like a tree with branches that are all feeding each other, all reaching for the same goal. And, like The Book of Accidents, Wendig shows patience in cultivating this tree, letting it evolve and shift with the seasons, pruning it just so, always making sure it’s primed for maximum beauty and maximum emotional punch.”
FanFiAddict: “Nothing short of a horrific saga, Black River Orchard is a story that embraces its terrifying weirdness with open arms. With a comprehensive backstory interwoven with the present narrative, Chuck Wendig has gifted us a gritty look into small-town persuasion and the horrors of falling to the masses. We are given many loveable (and hate-able) characters to empathize with and shake our fists at throughout the course of the plot without losing out on the action. A true example of balancing characterization and plot development, Black River Orchard will have me skipping the farmer’s market for the foreseeable future.”
Books Bones & Buffy: “Wendig’s story is complex and multilayered. In addition to the story playing out in the present, he delves into the past and shows the origins of the apple–at one time called the Harrowblack—and how it originally had ties to the indigenous Lenape. Over the years, the apple was lost, but Dan Paxton was able to revive it, which turned out to be a terrible idea. I also loved Wendig’s passion for his subject matter and his vivid descriptions of apples and their taste, texture and smell. I’ve always loved his writing, and it really shines in Black River Orchard.”
Nightmare Magazine, Adam-Troy Castro: “The story has plenty of ooga to float its booga. It’s all about a town beset by cursed apples, instantly addictive, that, as they become a delicacy, accentuate everything negative in the personalities of their consumers, rendering them selfish, evil, and ultimately murderous.”
The Southern Bookseller Review: “Black River Orchard hit me like a combination of Stephen King and really good Magnus Archives episode, in the best of ways. For my fellow booksellers, this book is a mix of Stephen King’s IT and Faust — like if Faust was an apple farmer, and then mix up layers of horror–there’s psychological horror of domestic abuse and being trapped, of seeing people change for the worse. There’s body horror. Hooo boy, there’s body horror. And on top of all of that, I learned about apples!”
Random Email: “I was looking forward to reading this book as I love horror, but the only horror was how elitist you came across. Good for you, you’re sooooo progressive because you mentioned trans, ENBY, a lesbian couple, sex dungeon, BDSM, bigots, stolen land, religious nuts, and non-vaxers? My daughter and I have books that come with trigger warnings about monster cocks, so you’re not special.” haha oh wait I already posted that one, sorry
As always, I politely note that me writing books is how I fund this here website, so if you dig that and dig my presence in this universe, checking out Black River Orchard from a bookstore or library is a good way to keep my soul tethered to the vacation resort that is my flesh. And if you have checked out the book, leaving a review at the usual receptacles (Amazon, Goodreads, Storygraph, TikTok) is a great way to keep the party going, too.
I note that for the next couple days, Bookshop.org is doing free shipping. You can buy Black River Orchard there, as a matter of fact. Or you can get a signed copy from Doylestown Bookshop or the four stores I’m visiting above.
I also note that the hardcovers for both Wayward and Book of Accidents appear to be on sale at AMZ, if you’re so inclined.
OKAY BYE
Beck says:
… So she didn’t like it, or…
Imagine getting this bunged up. Imagine being that person. Unreal. Has she not read your other books? Astonishing
October 10, 2023 — 1:41 PM
Michael Patrick Hicks says:
OK, but Trump supporters absolutely are deplorable cult members and in serious need of deprogramming, ASAP, and are the political enemy of anybody looking to progressively move this country forward and away from the 15th Century politics of the GOP. I can promise her and all other Trumpers that if they truly get their way, books about monster cocks will certainly make their way onto the book burning wagons.
October 10, 2023 — 1:42 PM
Margaret Flinner says:
Wow! I’m downloading it now from Audible! Loved Book of Accidents and the Wayward and Wanderers and miss your input to the Star Wars.
October 10, 2023 — 1:46 PM
conniejjasperson says:
Wow–the craziness. Well, good luck on your tour. Wish I could make it to the Elliot Bay Books thing, but grand kid’s 11th birthday comes first. Hope the rest of your emails are less disturbing.
October 10, 2023 — 1:59 PM
Karen says:
Somewhere there’s a tree working hard to produce the oxygen she wasted to create this, she needs to find it and apologize.
October 10, 2023 — 2:00 PM
Susan Annette Ridenour says:
*both thumbs up*
October 10, 2023 — 2:10 PM
Susan Annette Ridenour says:
The reviewer at the top reminds me of Brene Brown’s video on YouTube where she mentions The Man in the Arean speech by Roosevelt.
To take a snippet of her response/interpretation: If you’re not in the area, I’m not interested in your feedback [and] “The only guarantee you get if you put yourself out there to be seen is that you will get your ass kicked.”
October 10, 2023 — 2:08 PM
Jim Argendeli says:
Just picked up Black River Orchard. Looking forward to the read!
October 10, 2023 — 2:20 PM
christophergronlund says:
I hope this person’s email helps sell some copies among those who have not yet picked it up!
“I wasn’t sure I was going to get it, but…that email piqued my interest!”
October 10, 2023 — 2:49 PM
Ashley Adams says:
Dude. Your book is fucking brilliant and I loved it! I am a liberal living in South Carolina so I am familiar with the scary people such as the one that sent the above message to you. Thanks for sharing it so I know I am not the only one who deals with this shit. Carry on with all your badassness!
October 10, 2023 — 3:03 PM
Jennifer Gracen says:
I think Trigger Warnings About Monster Cocks should be the title of one of your books someday…
JFC, what you deal with sometimes. Yeeeesh.
October 10, 2023 — 3:10 PM
Melanie R. Meadors says:
Jen, can we co-write a book about monster cocks, PLEASE?
October 10, 2023 — 5:38 PM
Jennifer Gracen says:
Mel!! Hahahahahaha SURE WHY NOT
October 10, 2023 — 8:21 PM
Robert Bruinewoud says:
if one were to write about monster cocks, i’d suggest they be of the Ayam Cemani breed – a rare breed of chicken from Indonesia with a dominant gene that causes hyperpigmentation, making the chicken almost entirely black, including feathers, beak, and internal organs … totally metal!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayam_Cemani
October 10, 2023 — 10:46 PM
Charlie says:
This person clearly hasn’t ever read Wanderers.
October 10, 2023 — 3:11 PM
Rowan M. says:
this person could touch every blade of grass on the planet and it still might not be enough to restore their equanimity
October 10, 2023 — 3:22 PM
innerspacegirl says:
people be weird. will die on this hill, while simultaneously trying not to be too weird myself. YRMV.
October 10, 2023 — 3:30 PM
Old Newsboy says:
So…in your next book you’ll have monster cocks? And trigger warnings?
Cool.
October 10, 2023 — 3:41 PM
Dave Branson says:
I was planning to read this anyway, but now I might buy two copies.
I hope to make it to your Seattle event. While you’re in town, you should check out our rare local delicacy, the Red Delicious Apple. 😉
October 10, 2023 — 3:48 PM
Pamela says:
Like WOW—are sure an AI didn’t write this?
October 10, 2023 — 4:24 PM
David Archambault says:
Muahahaha! I will get to encounter you fresh on Friday! I will obtain your words and hopefully an apple of some form applied to my face!
October 10, 2023 — 5:36 PM
Melanie R. Meadors says:
My….DAUGHTER and I….???? I mean, hey, I’m all for monster cock, but I generally don’t share with my offspring…
October 10, 2023 — 5:37 PM
Kay Camden says:
I got stuck on that “My daughter and I” sentence too. How is this the entire email? For that sentence to just be in there like that with no other reference… just… ??
October 10, 2023 — 5:46 PM
Melanie R. Meadors says:
You know, I’m reading that sentence again, and I’m kind of wondering what she’s implying about you, Chuck…
October 10, 2023 — 5:43 PM
D. Ausgtin says:
I was going to get Black River Orchard, but after reading that e-mail, I dunno. The dearth of monster cocks gives me pause. I guess I could just mentally swap in “mega-dong” every time I read “apple.” Gotta think on this some more.
October 10, 2023 — 6:05 PM
Yo says:
Must politics be included in all art though? People look to art sometimes for a break from reality not reinforcement of it.
October 10, 2023 — 10:09 PM
terribleminds says:
Politics are included automatically — that’s not to say it means specific political references, like “Republican” or “Democrat,” but politics being the broad strokes definition of who has power and governance and who can execute on or be exploited by that power — it is in the work automatically. Even if you try to keep it out, the act of keeping it out is an act of putting it in.
October 11, 2023 — 7:53 AM
robinjambalayapluto83261 says:
I’m also at a loss as to how to keep politics out of literature. Putting aside the question whether this SHOULD be done or not – is it actually POSSIBLE to do it?
Can anyone think of a single widely read book (or even a not-so-well-known one) that was completely apolitical? It would have to be something totally abstract, and even then people would find ways to interpret what they read through a sociopolitical lens.
“People look to art sometimes for a break from reality not reinforcement of it.”
Do they, though?
Whenever I see this sort of critique in a book or movie review, 10/10 times it really means “I’m butthurt because I disagree with the positions you present in your work, but can’t articulate a coherent of factually supported argument against them, so rather than change my mind and embrace reality, I’m going to one-star your book/movie out of sheer pique”.
Besides, who the hell picks up a horror or science fiction book looking for mindless escapism?
October 12, 2023 — 4:36 PM
Leif says:
What’s weird is how both of you love honeycrisp apples. We all know Pink Lady apples are the best. Understand that those trees have monster stamens. Such on those juicy fruits instead.
October 11, 2023 — 2:22 PM
Alejandro De La Garza says:
Wow, Chuck! Someone didn’t like your book and felt compelled enough about it to relay their brutal opinion. I know you’re just devastated, and I feel your pain, brother. But I’m sure you’ll be able to pick up the tattered pieces of your life and move forward. Keep writing and keep fighting!
October 12, 2023 — 9:26 PM
Jennifer Hughes says:
“The fuckers.
There, I feel better.
God-damned human race.
There, I feel better.”
-Charles Bukowski
Might not mean much, but I love your books. Fuckers.
October 20, 2023 — 8:28 AM
Janine G Stinson says:
In contrast, I offer the multi-colored Ayam Ketawa rooster: its crowing call resembles that of a kookaburra (Australian bird).
November 2, 2023 — 4:04 PM
Echelon says:
LMAO! “My daughter and I have books that come with trigger warnings about monster cocks, so you’re not special….” – What the actual fuckery?! haHAHAHAHA
November 26, 2023 — 3:59 AM