Hey, I’m updating the blog theme a little bit here (er, maybe more than a little bit) so forgive any digital debris. Bless this mess, as the cross-stitch in the Southern home might say. The site has long been sort of… erm, crappy looking since I ditched the vulnerable theme of the past, and so I’m messing around and maybe settled on this design? Though more tweaks may be inbound. I am not entirely thrilled with the font here in the individual posts and may try to futz with that. Which probably means I’ll break it. Shrug.
Anyway, so I’m also thinking of doing shorter form content here — a lot of my posts here end up being REALLY LONG (much like my books, zing), and as such I figure some shorter-form stuff might be nicer. Less stressful on my part to hop here and write three paragraphs instead of, I dunno, 300.
As such, here is a short-form thing:
The Super Mario Brothers movie was absolute dogshit. I don’t usually like to write negative reviews because, who cares? Not everybody likes everything, nothing to learn there. So what. It’s fine. You may have also like this movie I’m about to punch in in the neck, and that’s also totally okay. You should like the things you like. There is nothing wrong with you for that.
But it sucked bad and I figured I’d talk about it a little just because from a storytelling vantage, I think it’s instructive to me. And here’s why: the narrative structure of the movie suffers from what I call the AND THEN THIS HAPPENED mode of storytelling. It’s basically the same kind of storytelling quality you would receive from, say, a four-year-old. And not a very savvy four-year-old, you feel me? Your basic, mid-level four-year-old is what I’m talking here. And that kid will tell a story like this:
AND THE KNIGHT FOUGHT THE DRAGON AND THEN KILLED THE DRAGON AND THEN HE WAS HUNGRY SO HE ATE A SANDWICH AND THE SANDWICH WAS MADE OF SCORPIONS AND HE ATE THEM ANYWAY AND THEN
This type of story is essentially a value-less, consequence-free flow of abstract information. It is a sequence of events hung like pretty lights; they hang together in the gentlest dip and look nice and illuminate the patio but that’s it. There’s no there there. The saying, “put a hat on a hat” is one that indicates that you’ve maybe put too fine a point on something, right? This is the opposite. There’s no hat on a hat because there’s no first hat. And that’s the Super Mario Brothers movie. Things happen. They mean nothing. There’s no IF/THEN consequence, there’s no BUT WHAT IF questions, there’s no emotional stakes, there’s no arc, there’s just lights hung on a line, in a row, gently glowing. It’s kind of dogshit.
(And here you might say, well, what did you expect? It’s a game based on a really simplistic video game where a mustachioed Italian plumber punishes angry dickheaded mushroom men with turtle shells he violently ripped from his Koopa foes. It’s a linear video game and not much happens, and so no, I didn’t expect much. But the Sonic movie, which… listen, I dunno that it’s great, but it’s at least a story. Things happen, things matter, it’s a lot better than you’d think. So they could’ve done something here. But didn’t. It’s fine. It’s all good. It made a bajillion dollars until Barbie kicked it in the mustache. Whatever. There you go. Enjoy. Bye. Oh. Buy my apple book. Thanky.)
Kari Wolfe says:
Your voice and short form don’t really go together. I always want to hear more from you, especially when you critique stories. I learn so much when you do that and I just need practice doing it myself, I suppose.
August 11, 2023 — 4:24 PM
Kari Wolfe says:
But I do understand that 3 paragraphs can be easier than 300
August 11, 2023 — 4:25 PM
Christine Chrisman says:
You do whatever length posts work for you and I’ll happily read them 🙂 your story commentaries are always good learning!
August 11, 2023 — 4:29 PM
Samuel Johnston says:
Thank you. I felt like I was taking crazy pills talking to people about this movie. I think the power of concentrated nostalgia substituted for story for a lot of folks.
I’m sure the script was weighed down with a list of must-haves that made things difficult for the writers: gotta have all the classic enemies, gotta have karts and rainbow road, gotta have Donkey Kong, et. al. That probably accounts for a lot of AND THEN THIS HAPPENED.
It also seems like Nintendo is determined to not give these characters any sort of personality, drives or back-story deeper than their (very iconic) looks and catch-phrases. Maybe something to do with universal worldwide appeal and inserting them into 50 different unrelated properties? That makes it pretty difficult to create movie magic.
August 11, 2023 — 4:31 PM
Joan Condell says:
The cross stitch in my Southern home says “F*ck All Y’all”. Just sayin’.
August 11, 2023 — 6:50 PM
Marc Criley says:
Now, the trailer for HBO Mario Kart that SNL put together shows promise.
August 11, 2023 — 8:42 PM
Judy Walker says:
So is that three *regular* paragraphs, or three *Chuck* paragraphs which (counts on fingers and toes) translates to roughly 5.7 paragraphs? 😉 Lower word count stakes sounds good, for writing and reading, though I will always wrestle my currently splintered attention for a deep Chuck dive (still legal in most states).
Also, hope you’re feeling better. If your voice doesn’t improve before the conference, just think of Phoebe’s Sexy Phlegm.
August 12, 2023 — 4:08 AM
Desiree S. Brown says:
I’ve been told it’s a “good” movie by some, but I think they love it for the nostalgia. I usually find movies made after video games disappointing. I personally haven’t seen it yet and feel like I should just to confirm my beliefs, but your post isn’t encouraging me to torture myself lol.
August 12, 2023 — 7:45 AM
Rebecca Ruth Seidel says:
As I was reading your first thoughts on the mario movie, I kept thinking “unlike Sonic!” which I’ve had the pleasure of half-watching over a dozen times because of my son. I’ve kept him away from the mario movie for the pure reason that I *don’t* want to end up having it play on loop, but maybe my kid would have better taste? I still don’t want to risk it
August 12, 2023 — 9:39 PM
terribleminds says:
Haha, we were blessed that our kiddo said, with the SMB movie, “that wasn’t very good.” Which then we got to talk about why that was. I do imagine it would work very well for littler kids?
August 13, 2023 — 10:17 AM