So, there’s this pandemic, right? A real corker of a coronavirus — some people get li’l colds, some people get pneumonia, others have organs attacked, suffer strokes, or endure long-lasting neurological symptoms. And we’ve no idea if there are longer-term problems waiting in the wings. Like I said the other day, polio could wage additional damage decades after you had it.
In this pandemic, we shut the country down. Sorta. Partly. Some states went whole hog, others half-assed it, and now we’re all varying degrees of “reopened,” and cases are surging. All because we didn’t do shit, really, as a country. Some states did well. My state, PA, is doing… pretty okay? Better than a lot, not as good as some of our Northeast counterparts. But nationwide, as a whole, we took allllllll that time locked down to accomplish… eeeyyyyeaaaannnhhh, very, very little.
And now, in many places, it’s worse than it was in March. Worse than the conditions that triggered the lockdown in the first place.
We were on a train driving toward a broken track over the edge of the cliff, and we wisely said, “We’d better slow this beast down, lest we go off the edge,” so we slowed it down… but then… kinda did nothing? We didn’t build new tracks. We didn’t construct a bridge. We didn’t even cover the train in pillows and bounce-houses in the hopes it lessened our impact, if we had to go over the cliff.
We just bided our time and then started speeding up again.
The track is still broken.
The cliff is still ahead.
And the train is full of children.
What I’m saying is, how the hell are we supposed to open schools again?
Consider the following problem —
Soon, it’s going to be cold-and-flu season. That can start as early as September around these parts, and really gets its roots in by winter. Hell, autumn brings allergies, too.
Now, let’s say a kid, or a teacher, starts to have symptoms of one or the other.
Sniffles, sneezes, runny noses, coughs. A temperature.
Is it COVID-19?
Well, you won’t know, so whaddya gonna do? Just casually remove them? The virus is catchier than a Rick-Roll, and often before you even show symptoms. You pretend it’s fine, you could make sure that everyone gets it, that it runs a race around everyone in school.
So, the likely answer is, you have to shut down the school, or at least that class, until the person is tested. And once again, testing is harder to get across the country. If you can get a test, then some people are receiving results in 7-14 days. For a while there it was faster, but remember SLOW DOWN THE TESTING, PLEASE, from our erstwhile shitberg of a president? Yeah. His wish was our command, and now testing is half-fucked again. So, if the person with the coughing-sniffles gets a test, it could be two weeks before results roll in.
Two weeks where people have to freak the fuck out that maybe their kids, or the teachers, or the parents, or whoever, caught the thing that may or may not be the virus that may or may not leave you with lasting long-time damage. That’s a very big Schroedinger’s Cat situation, isn’t it?
Then, then, assume that people are going to also get this thing. Not just cold. Not just flu. But people are going to get it. Statistically, that’s gonna happen, and I’m betting it happens in the first month of school. A kid, a teacher, an admin, a parent, or even someone secondarily connected to those people — a grandparent, a neighbor, whatever, someone where there has been exposure.
Now what?
Well, again, you probably gotta shut shit down.
So, best case scenario, you’ve got a rolling series of openings and shutdowns, blunting any educational momentum the kids and teachers gain. All while school is surely hamstrung anyway, because there’s no way you can run a school the way you did before in the midst of all this.
Given that even a single cough or elevated temperature could totally knee-cap your entire school for two weeks… how’s this supposed to work? What’s the point? Why even bother opening? It’s a futile gesture, like trying to thread a needle with a blowdart from across a crowded room. I guess it’s not impossible but oof. Of course, the Sword of Damocles hanging over everyone’s head is that parents have to work and that means they have to send their kids to school and then there are kids who need school for meals and education (obviously) and social growth and maybe even an escape from abusive or problematic families. But federally, we have no response for this, no planning, no way forward — and a lot of states don’t have much of a clue, either. So onward the train goes, chug-chug-chug, choo-choo, and we know the tracks are busted, we know there’s no bridge, it’s only a cliff ahead and a damning drop to the hard ground below. But we keep going. The train keeps a rollin’.
terribleminds says:
(For the record, this doesn’t even scratch the surface of how damning this is for teachers — who were already front-line vital workers helping all our children, and who are often tossed into an INFLUENZA BLENDER on a regular year. Now they’re being asked to lay on the altar, sacrificed to the cause.)
July 10, 2020 — 11:12 AM
Jen Merrill says:
Yes, exactly. My strongest hope right now is that Fourth of July revelry will result in a jump in cases, drop Illinois back to Phase 3, and schools won’t be able to open. It’s a no win situation and I hate hoping that people will get sick to prevent schools from opening, causing MORE people to get sick.
July 10, 2020 — 11:44 AM
Sarah says:
Also, consider that kids in most schools at least by years 6-12 are changing classes at least 4 times but as many as 7 times a day. So it isn’t just that class… it’s that class, that kid’s other classes, and every teacher of that kid… and all their classes too. It’s half the school exposed from one kid. Not to mention every family member of those folks etc etc it’s exponential.
July 14, 2020 — 2:04 PM
Willow Croft says:
Yeah, it’s going to be a real “rock and hard place” come fall when schools reopen…IN LESS THAN A MONTH FROM NOW BTW…I need my one-and-only-job-i’ve-been-able-to-get-in-ten-plus-years as a substitute teacher, but I’m just clobbered even thinking about being back in the already-germ-factory school system.
July 15, 2020 — 10:11 AM
Fenraven says:
Sending everyone back to school is gonna come close to spreading that virus coast to coast. I don’t even know what to say to that, I really don’t. I’ve been wearing my mask when I go out, staying home when I don’t have to be anywhere. I’ve even avoided the dentist, because I’m scared of catching it there. Now they want to force the schools to reopen. FORCE it. Trump is determined to make us ALL sick, isn’t he?
July 10, 2020 — 11:19 AM
A. Elizabeth West says:
I think you nailed it. Sick or dead people can’t vote against him.
July 11, 2020 — 3:38 PM
Megan says:
THIS. Every single word of it.
Signed, a public school educator
July 10, 2020 — 11:22 AM
Wendy Taylor says:
Thanks, Chuck. I’m with you 100% on this, and I’m only a county or two over in PA. I have been generally pleased with PA’s actions but the whole reopening and the schools — ugh. My kids did well with the online learning, so if that continues I’ll be relieved, but I know it doesn’t work as well or at all for a lot of people. But I am not equipped to homeschool my 12yo and 16yo at the levels they need, so I need the school infrastructure somehow. Sigh. What a mess.
July 10, 2020 — 11:22 AM
AARON says:
Maybe this is what those maniacs mean by the “Trump train”..?
July 10, 2020 — 11:24 AM
Claudia Nunn says:
I adore you! You and your stringing together of words!
July 10, 2020 — 11:25 AM
LoN says:
Fucking Criminal.
July 10, 2020 — 11:27 AM
Rebecca Douglass says:
I’ve been worrying over this. The only even semi-possible scenarios I’ve seen for how to reopen schools are going to cost a lot of money. This just in: our schools are grossly under-funded already. Then the shitberg (love that name!) says he’ll cut off even more money for schools that don’t… just open wide? WTAF?
July 10, 2020 — 11:40 AM
Kelly Clisham says:
Our district just announced a plan where kids will either go to school Monday/Tuesday or Thursday/Friday with deep-cleaning on Wednesdays and weekends.The other days will be virtual. I’m not sure I’m comfortable with that limited contact. I get the importance of in-person education, but I also really like having my kids alive. Plus they’re 17 and 13, and really tuned in to current events. How much learning will they do if they’re anxious messes and worried that they could die or transmit the virus and kill a family member whenever a classmate coughs? I don’t know what the answer is, but I’m scared.
July 10, 2020 — 11:52 AM
K Callard says:
I’m in Canada, and our case count isn’t as bad (though we’re all anticipating a second wave come September), but even here the school situation is looking ridiculous. Right now they’re suggesting the kids go to school 2-3 days/week, with a max of 15 kids/class. But then all those kids go off to daycare or grandparents or whatever on the off days (expanding the risk/exposure pool), while the teacher teaches the other 15 kids (thus linking the two classes).
Even if that was magically going to work, how are they going to keep parents from sending in sick kids? Or monitor which families are waiting on a Covid test & still send their kids?
At the very least all school boards should have distance learning set up for those parents who don’t feel safe (high risk kids or family members, or just afraid) which could then be utilized by families when (not if) classes/schools get closed & quarantined.
July 10, 2020 — 12:06 PM
Kay Camden says:
I know parents who’d rather risk their kids than have to deal with the school-at-home thing. I just can’t get my head around that.
July 10, 2020 — 12:08 PM
LoN says:
Feel super lucky to be in lower NY and camp is open but in small pods – 4 kids in my daughters group and mostly outside. Just hoping this holds.. but the way things are going… the mess everywhere else. All the hard work going down in flames.
July 10, 2020 — 12:17 PM
J.S. Mueller says:
Your article echoed my thoughts, opinion & concerns perfectly. I’ve been saying all of this for a couple weeks now, and it irritates the bejesus out of me that we were flattening the curve for a while and then just blew it all to hell. Basically, all that quarantining for nothing. Other countries are getting back on track, and we still don’t have mass, drive-through, free testing for citizens. What we have are a lot of “Wearing-A-Mask-Is-Encroaching-On-My-Right-To-Be-A-Completely-Selfish-Dickwad” types who should be herded up and airlifted to some remote island.
We in KY have a great governor, who just mandated masks in public, but we also have a large number of stupid people who you know are going to pitch tantrums over it…
July 10, 2020 — 12:20 PM
theycallmetater says:
I’m from Kentucky but live in Maryland now. I’ve already seen angry posts from high school friends about the mask mandate.
July 10, 2020 — 1:13 PM
David Poole says:
My wife is a 1st grade teacher. She pointed out that schools can’t even control head lice and _we can see those_. She’s planning to go back to school in the fall because what choice do we have other than quitting? School principals and teachers are working hard to figure out how to make this happen but no one is happy about it.
July 10, 2020 — 12:23 PM
churnage says:
Are kids going to social distance? No.
Are they going to wear masks and wear them properly? Probably not.
What happens when you have a bunch of defiant teenagers who refuse to wear masks?
What about school buses, cafeterias and stats and dismissals?
Don’t drink the bleach, peeps!
July 10, 2020 — 12:30 PM
Christopher says:
I am a teacher and in a higher risk category. I live in a town that has been largely untouched by the virus. Over the last weeks we have had a slight uptick of cases. The school district has told us we are going back to school next month full time with regular class size. They I’ll try to provide masks for everyone. Other than that…good luck. I am a little bit terrified.
July 10, 2020 — 12:42 PM
vwreck says:
I can’t think of a viable alternative to not sending them back. If we don’t send them back, we need to ensure parents are guaranteed the option of working from home, or–if they’re not office workers–somehow supported while they’re not working, and not penalized for it. All while not putting heavy burdens and workloads on those without children. I figure we’ll start to see day cares for the young ones pop up that offer assistance with the kids’ online classes. That’s definitely worse than putting them back in schools. Our society was simply not made for this. It’s a lose-lose situation.
July 10, 2020 — 12:54 PM
Christopher Daley says:
The problem I have with this is that people are deciding I get to be one of the acceptable losses.One third of the teachers in America can retire on the spot right now. What happens if they decide it isn’t worth the risk? How do you replace them? Last year my school district couldn’t find substitute teachers. The solution was to put those students in other classrooms, temporarily overcrowding them. There wasn’t a day during flu season last year where I didn’t have a student out sick. Combined with several in my classroom who were sick but sent to school anyway. How do we handle all of these situations? I believe kids need to be in school. I also believe i deserve the right to be as safe as I can possibly be made. Right now there is no plan. My school district and many like mine threw up there hands and said back to normal. Wear a mask. Hope it works out. That was the extent of the plan.
July 10, 2020 — 3:03 PM
Tanya Stewart says:
All of us—and our offspring—are considered acceptable losses by the sociopaths in power in this country. They simply do not care who and how many die, as long as they can continue to wallow in their money-centered, worthless lives. If the majority of parents refused to send their children to school, and teachers, administrators, and staff refused to go to work, without a successful vaccine available free to everyone—in effect, a nation-wide strike—there might be some major fuses blown in the upper echelons of power.
July 10, 2020 — 7:20 PM
theycallmetater says:
Dealing with how this changes college is hard enough. I can’t imagine having a K-12 kid during this.
July 10, 2020 — 1:14 PM
cchrisman says:
ugh so true. i’m in california, where it seems like we did all this work and did a great job, and then what the actual f***? for what? seems like a huge waste, like the country has thrown up it’s collective hands and is just gonna let people die.
depressing as hell
July 10, 2020 — 1:33 PM
Amy Aajee says:
I’m hoping that with all the masks, distancing, and hand washing we won’t have much of a cold and flu season. You, know, just a little pandemic to deal with.
July 10, 2020 — 1:57 PM
Wendy Christopher says:
Here in the UK, the schools situation has been weird, to say the least. Technically, they never completely shut, even through the lockdown, because parents who were essential workers and couldn’t get childcare to cover for their children being at home were allowed to still bring their kids into school, where the (reduced) staff acted as teachers/surrogate childminders until the parents could pick them up again. The numbers were obviously a lot fewer than if the schools were still open, but, still…
Then, at the beginning of June, there was a ‘phased re-opening.’ Reception, Year 1 and Year 6 pupils returned to school first (US equivalent would be the first two and last years of first-graders.) This was followed a couple of weeks later by Years 7, 10 and 12 in secondary education (middle-graders and High School.) The government plans to have all schoolchildren returning to school in September at the start of the new term, but – well, we’ll see what’s going on with the virus when that rolls around…
How’s that gone for us? Well, even though we have succeeded in ‘flattening the curve’ like the rest of Europe, we don’t currently have the third-highest death rate in the world for nothing. (That’s also due to the APPALLING way care homes were thrown under the bus by this government, but that’s a whole other story…) I don’t know if any of this information is reassuring to you guys in the US or not. I’m hoping you can all get through this, and you too will start to ‘flatten the curve’ soon.
July 10, 2020 — 2:09 PM
WeAreOnTheLoose says:
I really think this moment calls for a wholesale reworking and reimagining of how schools and parents work in our economy, the pandemic is just bringing to light all the issues and ways in which public education hasn’t really been working for everyone or fully funded for years…but do we have the heart and brains to do that as a country? I think not and so parents and families and schools will be left to the wolves of figuring it out piecemeal as usual, with all the inequality that means for most.
July 10, 2020 — 3:27 PM
Michelle Held says:
YES!!! The whole system is broken and has been for at least 30 years. Use the knowledge gained from alternative and charter schools. Pay Moms to stay home with small kids, or offer training to homeschool. Funnel older kids toward trades or careers at a younger age. Teach citizenship and history and democracy. Teach biology in a forest or math with an astronomer. Retool the whole damn process! Do we have the courage and perseverance to do nything like this? I think that’s doubtful, but I can still dream!
July 11, 2020 — 3:18 PM
alyssabethancourt says:
I don’t get why this issue, like every other one, has become so needlessly politicized (except I do and it’s because that’s how They want us — sniping at each other instead of unifying for the common good.) Naturally we ALL want our kids to be safe, and have an education, and to get the socialization with their peers that they need for healthy development. It’s no one’s CHOICE that shit is fuckered right now. That’s not how anyone wants it. The insistence by some people that The Left is cheering about there being a horrible virus holding us all hostage — cheering at the fact that we haven’t yet worked out the safest way to get our kids everything they need when the school year starts — is nothing short of bonkers. No one wants this. The choices are all bad and we all hate it. The virus doesn’t have a political alignment any more than gravity does.
UGH I hate how tribally fractured they’ve managed to make us. Public health is a matter for cooperation, not debate!
July 10, 2020 — 4:24 PM
Piccadilly Jilly says:
We are in the county one over from Chuck’s. My older son found out today that the community college will be having all classes online this coming school year. It looks like my younger son (going into 9th grade) will have the option of attending school in person or online. Our school district is in the process of defining both curriculum’s and are supposed to present the plans at the end of the month. An alternative would be to have my son attend the PA Charter School which is a virtual school. My neighbor is one of their teachers and is also considering for her own children.
I’d love my son to be able to start high school this year, but the health risks are too great considering the AAP (American Academy of Pediatrics) and the CDC can’t agree on safety restrictions and requirements, one being how far apart desks should be. AAP says three feet is adequate. CDC says six feet. Is three feet enough? I don’t know. Does it matter how far apart the desks are if everyone is wearing a mask? Maybe not. But maybe. Considering the likelihood of everyone in school wearing a mask that covers their mouth and nose, all day long AND not touching their eyes, nose or mouth AND social distancing is slim, we are seriously considering having our son do one of the online alternatives. We are fortunate that I’m able to work from home and he needs minimal assistance with school work so online classes would be fine for him. Other families are not so fortunate. If this was happening when my older two children were younger, it would have been a more difficult decision to make. Both of them are on the Autism Spectrum, high functioning, but each with their own learning issues. Online learning would not have been easy for them and even as an adult, I know my older son will struggle with his online college courses this year, but that’s OK. My husband and I will support him as best we can. That’s all we really can do right now. That’s all anyone can do with the current situation.
July 10, 2020 — 6:41 PM
furyious says:
Here’s the thing that worries me, Chuck. All these governors who want to pretend everything is okay and their rose colored glasses are now a burning neon pink, have just completely ignored that children and young people are contracting this virus. Those that are surviving are come out of the other side of the viral battlefield with scarred lungs, damaged kidneys, blood clots that lead to heart attack and strokes, not to mention the brain damage. Really, isn’t ONE SINGLE CHILD too many? I’m so grateful my granddaughter is not school age. I’m even more grateful that my son and son in law are working remotely from home with no end date. I wish I were.
This thing is dangerous to everyone, old, young, blue, red. People should be scared. The Walking Dude is cruising Route 66 and he’s whistling a happy tune.
July 10, 2020 — 6:44 PM
L. Raymond says:
Here in Houston, our mayor is basically ripping his hair out trying to do the right things while Trump, our governor and all the of the GOP are just knee-capping him. Some of our suburban school districts have the infrastructure in place to start the school year virtually, others, like the Houston school district – the biggest school district in the state (!) – don’t, and have to have in person classes. We’re going to lose so many children this year.
For special irony, the state GOP is planning to sue the city for cancelling their state convention which was going to be here in town. They wouldn’t agree to institute distancing or require masks, so for their own good Mayor Turner cancelled their contract with the city’s arena.
July 10, 2020 — 7:11 PM
R.L. Merrill says:
26-year public school educator here. Just applied to transfer to teach virtual school. Also registered my 14yo son to go to virtual school. I’m also immunocompromised. If they don’t let me work from home I’ll have to take a leave. I’ve already had one scare with COVID (negative but still really sick). Our schools in CA have 36-40 kids in 6-12th grades. They don’t clean our schools as is. I have Zero faith that schools will be able to protect teachers or kids from getting sick. This country hasn’t cared about sending us to be sitting ducks with school shooters, why should they care now, other than they are inconvenienced? I feel for families who have no choice. I worked My ass off for my students this past spring and did the best I could to keep them all engaged. Please vote, people. And complain to your school districts. Let them know you’re afraid. Change will never happen if we don’t speak up. Thank you, Chuck.
July 10, 2020 — 8:09 PM
Ella says:
Don’t discount teachers handling the situation. My son is a teacher at a large high school and trust me, there is a network of them working in the background. Most schools will open for a week at best, before the numbers require they shut down. Picture waking up to teacher’s unions all over the country calling for a strike because they required teachers to work in unsafe conditions. They’ll do it for themselves and their students. Just watch.
July 11, 2020 — 6:12 PM
Theresa Meyers says:
I would much rather be in the classroom teaching, than online. It’s a better method and better for the students for certain.
But let me paint you a picture of what our high school is like so you can understand why the CDC guidelines will be so incredibly difficult to follow.
I’ve been in the hallway during passing period, when the kids are packed shoulder to shoulder, bodies crushed up against one another like a New York subway every hour and a half throughout the day.
There is physically not enough space in our building to put 2500 students six feet apart.
Students are not going to follow the guidelines when they don’t even follow school rules.
They are going to share their water bottles and energy drinks. They are going to hold hands and touch one another giving high fives. They are going to share Jules, kiss and share clothing, accessories and grooming supplies even if we tell them not to and will think they are being stealthy by doing it out of sight if the adults.
I have four different kids sit at each desk during the day and all the desks touch one another just to fit 30 of them in my classroom.
I have only one bathroom with about eight stalls on my floor for all the students on that floor and they often come late to class waiting just to use a stall, let alone washing their hands.
I have a room with no windows and a ventilation system from 1980. Two of the three walls in my classroom are folding walls and you get air and sound coming in from the other two adjoining classrooms which also have no windows.
We have the students eat in four lunch periods back to back and they are crowded in at long tables facing one another. The entire lunch/commons area is all high touch because students move back and forth through it during passing.
I teach approximately 180 kids a week. And each kid has eight classes. Try contract tracing that. And don’t forget that time they are hanging out before and after school, sitting for sometimes an hour, three to a bus seat, to and from school.
Do I want to go back? Absolutely. Do I think we can do it safely if we go back to what it was last fall? No freakin way. Schools are Petri dishes of the highest magnitude. Getting sick is an absolute given. In fact my best friend who teaches third grade said last week, “You know we are getting this, right? You can’t teach in person and not get it.” So am I nervous? Hell yes. Unlike the checker at your grocery store I’m not given gloves and have only a fabric mask, not a plexiglass shield. Unlike the nurse, I get no PPE suit, goggles or high filtration mask. I get a bottle of hand sanitizer. I’m worried about the health of my students, their families, the staff, myself and my family. And no one has explained yet how they plan to make this work or pay for it.
July 14, 2020 — 4:49 PM
rocketpj says:
High School kid is going to be completely online. He did well in the Spring with it (the alternative of sitting with me supervising was perhaps too much to bear).
10 year old was completely miserable and depressed after 4 weeks of isolation. After 8 weeks he was hostile and furious, all day. When the schools opened part-time in June (here in BC) with 2 days/week his life and mood became vastly better.
We did well this year, comparatively. Certainly much better than the Empire in Collapse to our immediate South. But September is going to get nasty for all of us.
July 22, 2020 — 3:47 PM