I said this on Twitter but I want to say it here, too:
So, you’re sitting there as a writer and you’re getting sucker-punched by feelings of fear and doubt. You’ll find yourself face to face with uncertainty over whether or not you deserve success, and the certainty that one day you’ll be found out as an imposter and dragged out into the streets. Where hobos will pee on you.
WHERE HOBOS WILL PEE ON YOU.
I’ve got two books out soon — GODS & MONSTERS UNCLEAN SPIRITS and THE BLUE BLAZES — and this week folks are starting to get ARCs and e-ARCS of the latter of those books and all the while I’ve got that flurry of fear-bubbles in my tummy: egads they won’t like it they’ll despise it I’m going to receive hate mail people might punch me Kirkus and Publisher’s Weekly will probably give me whatever the opposite of a starred review is like maybe they’ll rub a cat’s butthole on my face in public OH GODS THAT’S HOW BAD THIS BOOK IS.
I like to hope it’s a silly fear. The book is getting published. Early readers liked it. My agent let it out the door. The publisher let it in the door. How bad can it be?
But that doesn’t matter. That’s rational. Fear and doubt aren’t rational.
So, to all writers of all stripes —
We all feel this.
We all feel like stowaways on the ISS Penmonkey, sometimes.
We all feel like we don’t belong. That one day our clever ruse will be up.
It seems to lessen over time. It’s better now for me than it was ten years ago. But it’s still there. That haunting specter. That nagging goblin. That ghostly whiff of hobo urine.
Whenever you feel that sense of urgent doubt nibbling at your bowels like a gut-load of rats, know you’re not alone. Somewhere out there some other writer is feeling it. A writer yet unpublished. A mid-lister, a self-published, a Stephen King, the ghost of Marcel Proust.
We are all bound to one another by the ropes of our uncertainty.
Sharing that frequency of heebie-jeebies and jittery jangly nerves.
The best we can do is help one another dispel those fears.
Or, at times, just merely to commiserate.
authorlady22 says:
Word.
April 10, 2013 — 12:05 AM
mcgeejp says:
Thanks, brother.
April 10, 2013 — 12:10 AM
Michala says:
Much appreciated knowing you get those same thoughts/feelings.
April 10, 2013 — 12:14 AM
Alan Baxter says:
A timely post. I’ve been running a guest series on my blog the last few days dealing with exactly this from some of Australia’s most successful writers. You can find the last one here, with links to the previous posts – http://www.alanbaxteronline.com/ongoing-angst-successful-writers-6-margo-lanagan/
Tomorrow I’m gong to do a wrap up of those and I’ll include a link to this post too.
April 10, 2013 — 12:21 AM
marlanesque says:
As someone who just released a manuscript to beta readers, this post is relevant to my interests.
April 10, 2013 — 12:55 AM
Amanda Corlies says:
It’s nice to know I have ropes of uncertainty binding me. That actually helps. Thanks, Chuck!
April 10, 2013 — 1:02 AM
alshultzauthor says:
Well, if even you can feel this way Chuck…then I guess I’m not in too bad of shape! PS, I do not want Hobos to pee on me!
April 10, 2013 — 1:22 AM
Jessa Slade says:
> How bad can it be?
I try to tell myself this, but tragically, my writer brain can rip out a baker’s dozen escalating scenarios on EXACTLY how bad it can be.
April 10, 2013 — 1:23 AM
LGVazquez says:
If there was only a way to harness that same creative energy we use to make up such hanious scenerios….
April 10, 2013 — 9:49 PM
Patrick O'Duffy says:
We can also get each other drunk.
It helps. It helps SO MUCH.
April 10, 2013 — 1:30 AM
Laura Libricz says:
Cheers!
April 11, 2013 — 12:33 PM
Erica says:
I certainly feel this way, and I wish I had your flare for articulating these things. “Where hobos will pee on you,” and “Like maybe they’ll rub a cat’s butthole in my face in public.” Ha! My writing feels so tame and prim in comparison. Gaaaaah, I’m doing it! Feeling inadequate.
Sadly, writing isn’t the only place I feel like an imposter 😛
Thanks for making me laugh!
April 10, 2013 — 1:55 AM
karenprince0 says:
Brilliant! This makes me want to press on. I get to the point where I imagine every author except me is supremely talented and bangs out a brilliant book every couple of months almost as an aside to the writing of their stellar blog posts. Knowing you have your moments is a huge comfort.
“cat’s butthole” !!!
April 10, 2013 — 3:03 AM
Nana Prah says:
Thanks. Knowing that you are afraid too makes me feel better about my insecurities.
April 10, 2013 — 3:57 AM
Q says:
“WHERE HOBOS WILL PEE ON YOU.”
You are fantastic. And this is timely, considering I’ve been angsting the past couple days over betas having my book. No matter the art form, I always feel like an imposter. Guess it’s time for a re-read of Art and Fear.
Thanks for this.
April 10, 2013 — 4:11 AM
joeturner87 says:
Did a post in a similar vein, though it was more about my own lacklustre performance than the one which encompasses us all. However it is comforting (sorry) to know that even fully fledged writers still dance with doubt. Thanks, Chuck.
April 10, 2013 — 4:58 AM
deadlyeverafter says:
Exactly what I needed to hear today after finishing one novel this week and querying another and EVERYONE WILL LAUGH AT ME AND STEAL MY BOOK BAG. Thanks, Chuck. This is why I dig through your trash.
–Julie
April 10, 2013 — 6:08 AM
Tania Roxborogh says:
Just letting you know that I copy and paste your some of your posts but redact the language and imagery (hilarious though it is) and share it with my writing students (who are under 18 and attend a church school). I ALWAYS reference you and your blog address so that, should they wish (and some of them tell me they do) they can read you in the raw (so to speak) – not sure what’s up with my need to use parenthesis tonight but that’s the way it blows tonight. Cheers and thanks for the post – needed it.
April 10, 2013 — 6:22 AM
Jessica says:
The official term for this is: The Imposter Syndrome.
It happens everywhere – business, academia, technical communities. You get in and start thinking, “All these people are some much better/smarter/more amazing than me. They’ll figure out I’m just bluffing.” The result is that you get a whole load of really clever/talented/dedicated people paranoid that someone will catch them out and throw them out of the club. So they work like hell to avoid being caught out.
So quite often the people who are among the most successful in their respective fields get there because they suffer the Imposter Syndrome and spend a huge amount of time and effort trying not to get caught. In writing, this would be: “I’m not nearly as talented as all these wonderful authors I’m reading, I’d better work extra hard on my edits so people don’t notice I’m not really a good writer.”
The problem is that you can’t see into everyone else’s head so you can’t tell if they’re feeling exactly the same thing.
April 10, 2013 — 6:28 AM
John Mantooth (@busfulloflosers) says:
I am totally right there with you. My first novel comes out in June, and not a day goes by where I don’t feel like somebody is going to call me up and say it was all a big mistake.
April 10, 2013 — 8:36 AM
Belly Peterson says:
Hey, Chuck, I really like this post about hobos peeing on a cat’s butthole! I want to hear more about these hobos and their pee adventures.
April 10, 2013 — 8:44 AM
kevinhearne says:
Truth, my friend. Also: Nobody knows the tacos I have seen. Nobody knows the salsa.
April 10, 2013 — 9:04 AM
terribleminds says:
I hope to sing this with you in San Antonio, sir.
April 10, 2013 — 9:23 AM
B.J. Keeton says:
I know this very well. I’m an indie author, and within the past month, two of my projects were finally ready to be released. It’s terrifying. Each new review that comes in is wonderful and terrible. And since one of them was the fulfillment of a Kickstarter project that funded last year, I feel even more fear of inadequacy.
But they’re selling well, and while the reviews have been critical, they haven’t been negative. But every day, I wait on that one star review that just says “It’s pooptastic” whether it is or not.
April 10, 2013 — 9:05 AM
tigs (@syzara) says:
Thanks, Chuck. This is exactly what I need today.
April 10, 2013 — 9:11 AM
Kelly says:
Very timely, tho’ for another reason. Feeling fed up with the whole writing thing, ready to, at the very least, give it a long break. Nice to know others feel the same. How could they not, obviously, but nice to have it confirmed.
April 10, 2013 — 9:13 AM
Noel Thompson says:
awesome website visit this really interesting website to be amazed http://www.thejetstream.com
April 10, 2013 — 9:19 AM
Francis Knight says:
Oh gods do I ever feel this!
Someone (I’m afraid I can’t recall who, sorry) recently said something that sums it up perfectly for me:
Anyone making something creative lives at the intersection of terror and joy
The OMG THIS IS SO AWESOME, swiftly followed by the kick in the koalas that is OMG THIS SUCKS SO BADLY AND SO DO I!
It’s just one of the many ways writers send themselves mad. (If you’d like a comprehensive list of authorial insanity, try this one: http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/004307.html )
Luckily for me, I’m bipolar so I’m kinda used to it….but I think most writers are just that tiny bit bipolar this way too. At least we’re all in it together! We are, aren’t we?
April 10, 2013 — 9:21 AM
Terri Herrington says:
I can’t wait to read them! (Sigh, I guess I’ll have to get comfy with the butterflies in my stomach when I write, since apparently they’re here to stay.)
April 10, 2013 — 9:50 AM
Mike (@NewGuyMike) says:
Zen breathing.
This is helpful. This kind of stuff has helped me realize the reason why I’ve been a surly jerk for the last two weeks is that I’m running background agida since my first finished novel is sitting in beta reader’s laps. And they’re being slow what with the whole ‘They’ve got lives’ thing. Pfft. Lives.
But seriously. Solidarity helps.
Also, you can just take my money now if you want.
April 10, 2013 — 9:54 AM
mznetta says:
*phew* I wondered what that stench was. Hobo pee. Now everything makes sense.
Been feeling the burn on this new project. Thanks for the insight. Seriously.
But now I have to take a shower.
April 10, 2013 — 10:09 AM
ergeller57 says:
Do not fear the din of disrespect. Fear the smothering silence of the abyss.
There–happy now?
April 10, 2013 — 10:14 AM
csoffer says:
Thanks, man. Just…thanks.
April 10, 2013 — 12:40 PM
Will Weisser says:
Does anyone else have problems with the ghost of Marcel Proust not leaving them alone? He keeps waking me up at night and asking for a madeleine, and when I tell him I don’t even know what that is he just says “Quoi?”
April 10, 2013 — 1:04 PM
amykossblogthang says:
Thanks. You’re a cutie-pie.
April 10, 2013 — 1:17 PM
Cat York says:
It looks very cool, Chuck. Did Joey Hi-fi do this cover too? I love it.
April 10, 2013 — 1:46 PM
Scott Zachary says:
I was whining to my better half the other day on how reading James Joyce was making me depressed because he’s so effortlessly good. Then I remembered, 1) it wasn’t effortless for him, 2) he had his moments of self-doubt, 3) comparing myself to Joyce is like a toddler fingerprinting in poo and then comparing himself to Michelangelo. She suggested I read something that was abysmally bad, and yet published, to get my spirits up. Nothing like a healthy dose of Schadenfreude, eh?
April 10, 2013 — 2:04 PM
Laura says:
Thank you, thank you, for this incredibly well-timed post. I’m preparing a short story for submission–the first one in a while, and to a rather popular magazine–and I am feeling ALL THE FEELINGS. Best to just choke those down, and put out the best work I can.
April 10, 2013 — 3:39 PM
sfummerton says:
Thank you for this. If you’ve been writing for ten years, I’m sure you’ve passed that 10,000 hours rule of mastering a talent or skill that Malcolm Gladwell writes about in “The Outliers”, and you know your stuff. But, it is strangely comforting to hear that even you have eagles performing aerial routines in your stomach. And even if some folk don’t like your novels, it’s probably going to be because they aren’t fans of the genre, or maybe some of the ideas or themes in your stories will just fly over their heads. Different strokes for different folks.
I’m planning a book launch on April 28th, and I’ll probably tell at least one person who purchases “Thaumaturge” that if he/she doesn’t like it, the book would make a dandy support for that uneven leg on the dining room table.
April 10, 2013 — 3:57 PM
DTWynne says:
It’s good to hear this from someone whose writing I think kicks ass. I also have ARCs going out right now for Steel Breeze, and I just have to immerse myself in other stuff to not think about it.
My wife reminds me that I had the same nerves before sending the book to betas and before sending it to my editor. She reminds me that all of those people liked it and they’re not idiots, but I fret and obsess anyway.
April 10, 2013 — 4:05 PM
Susan Spann says:
Thanks for this. Considering that my ARCs flew the coop (literally…USPS took them from their little publisher nests out into the big, bad, hobo-pee-filled-world this week) I’m having exactly these thoughts right now.
Something else that helps? ARTISAN CUPCAKES. May I recommend double chocolate and/or lemon-curd filled sour lemon with extra icing. Because cupcakes are TOTALLY the antidote to hobo pee baths.*
*Disclaimer: These claims have not been tested or bathed in the urine of transients. The author of this paragraph has never actually bathed in hobo pee. Your mileage may vary.
April 10, 2013 — 4:44 PM
Aspen Gainer says:
God, this is seriously so encouraging from a published author. A little depressing to know that it never goes away, but mostly encouraging that those feelings of doubt are normal even once you’ve been published. Thanks for sharing and for the encouragement!
April 10, 2013 — 5:04 PM
Danzier says:
Oh, so very true. This is why I beta-read: I then have the right to say “You don’t suck, and I can prove it!” while secretly reaffirming my own book’s validity, too. Postitve progress.
April 10, 2013 — 6:41 PM
UrsulaV says:
One thing I’ll give winning a Hugo–and there’s a post around this time every year where people try to dissect exactly what one’s worth in terms of money, future money, past money, glory, fame, etc, all of which could ALSO be said about the Campbell*–is that it freed me from feeling that I was a total imposter.
Now I just feel that my best work is behind me and I’m resting on my laurels and phoning everything in and they’re gonna HATE this next book, it’s such total fluff clearly I didn’t spend any time on it and it SHOWS and maybe I did something good ONCE but that’s all over now and it was totally a one-off and I’ll be doomed to increasingly watered-down parodies of myself until I am eventually hit by a bus and then everybody will be GLAD at my funeral.
I never knew my anxieties could level up before.
*aka the Nottahugo
April 10, 2013 — 7:23 PM
Toni says:
I will never be glad at your funeral, ma’am. I wonder how many other prolific and award-winning authors fear the title of “has been” after they accept that they’re clearly not deserving of the “imposter” label. (Anyone have Stephen King on speed-dial? We could ask him.)
Frankly, I suspect it’s more of an artist thing than strictly a writer thing, including actors, singers, writers, painters… really anyone who has achieved a level of success from which he or she would not like to fall. (Maybe it’s one of the reasons child actors fall apart when they’re no longer children?)
As for me, I look forward to reading your new (and future) books every bit as much as I did your already-published ones. And I thank you for opening up to us so honestly.
April 11, 2013 — 1:27 AM
Dave Hughes says:
This is so dead-on accurate for any creative endeavor. And now, because you can’t reach through the screen and stop me, here are a couple of non-writing personal stories on this.
First, over my 27 year career in broadcast radio, I have written and produced 1.328 metric butt tons of radio advertising copy, which (if it’s effective) should follow a very narrative format…except in thirty seconds. I’ve won right at thirty state and national awards for my copy, and in all but two cases I assumed the judges had lost their minds.
After EVERY…SINGLE…AWARD I’ve won in my career, I’ve thought “Well, that’s the last time that will happen. Sooner or later, they’re going to figure out I’m just winging it.”
I’m still waiting for that to happen, which of course means that not only do they lack good taste, but the judges are apparently really slow to catch on.
It’s taken me a long time to realize that what stands out to me as a glaring flaw in a commercial I’ve written, one that ruins the entire thing in my mind…well, to everyone else, THEY DON’T EVEN NOTICE IT.
I know this, I understand this, I live with this…and I still get surprised when someone brags on one of my commercials.
(On a side note: The scripts that have won me the biggest awards were, almost without exception, my least-favorites of the things I’ve ever churned out. Not only do I worry for no good reason, apparently I have crappy taste, too.)
My second story. When I was 12 (around 1980 or so), I ran across an add for a national poetry contest in Writer’s Digest Magazine. As I read it, I said to myself “Hey self, you can do this!” and composed what I thought was a decent poem and mailed it in.
The damn thing came in second nationally, and they mailed me a check for $250, which for a preteen in 1980 was the equivalent of striking oil in a casino when you knocked the poker table over as they handed you your winning lottery ticket.
(As I recall, I bought a TON of MEGO superhero action figures, and a stack of books as tall as Hervé Villechaize.)
You could have used my confidence to cut diamond when I got that check…until some well-meaning relatives started to bombard me with “Well, that doesn’t happen very often, so don’t be disappointed when it doesn’t happen again” and “That was fantastic! Not many people ever do that well, so you should really be proud of it happening for you once; you can’t expect that kind of thing all the time!”
Or that one bitter artist in my extended family, who took the time to call my twelve-year-old self and explain that I had done well, but “shouldn’t expect to succeed like that again unless I put in the years and years and YEARS it would take” to get back to that level.
You know…the level I WAS ALREADY FREAKIN’ AT.
To be honest, I hadn’t really given it much thought until I sat down to type this, but they did manage to protect me from disappointment…I have written very little poetry in the years since, and never put one out into the world.
It’s about time to fix that. SCREW HELPFUL PEOPLE TRYING TO LET YOU DOWN EASY ON SOMETHING THEY DON’T KNOW A TINKER’S DAMN ABOUT.
The trouble with other people trying to “let you down easy” is that you already agree with them before they say a word, so easy or not, you take that “let down” almost with a sense of relief. After all, everyone wants to fell like they’re right…especially about how much they believe they’re wrong.
April 10, 2013 — 11:30 PM
Lisa Marie says:
I went to a college that floated [and still floats] in a pool of this self-doubt. In the opening address to the freshmen/old broads who decided to go back and get that freaking degree, the dean of students discussed the this elephant in the room. She said that every single student here feels or will feel at least once that she is the only mistake the admissions office ever made. It was comforting. I felt a bit better. Then I thought, “Yeah, but in my case, it’s actually true. I am the mistake.”
I realize that I will never write like Jane Austen. I realize, too, that if Jane Austen still wandered around, she would never write the way I do.
I just wish I felt like this was actually a good thing,
April 11, 2013 — 12:38 AM
M G Bulmer (@goldenoldenlady) says:
I have a friend who – episodically – feels like this about her ENTIRE LIFE! Like, if everyone knew what and who “she really is”, no-one would employ her or love her, not her dearerst friends, her partner, her children even. This is usually when she is exhausted, worn to a rag with fatigue.
Anxiety is a bastard, isn’t it?
April 11, 2013 — 5:41 AM
chelsearthompson says:
Sounds a little like ACOA issues, if you don’t mind my saying. I used to feel like this about every aspect of my life, and I know how exhausting it can be. I hope she finds the support she needs to truly be free.
April 12, 2013 — 1:19 AM
talle says:
If I could just figure out how to have the terror, overanticipation of disaster, and self abasement AFTER I finish the stories instead of before/instead of…
April 11, 2013 — 8:14 AM
Devon Lynn says:
So glad I decided to catch up on my blog reading this morning. This makes twice that I’ve read something here that I really needed to read today. Thank you, thank you, thank you!
April 11, 2013 — 10:46 AM
Devon Lynn says:
And by that, I mean twice today. Not just twice overall.
April 11, 2013 — 10:47 AM