I’m a panster at heart, plotter by necessity — and I always advocate learning how to plot and plan because inevitably someone on the business side of things is going to poke you with a pointy stick and say, “I want this.” Thus you will demonstrate your talent. Even so, in choosing to plot on your own, you aren’t limited to a single path. And so it is that we take a look at the myriad plotting techniques (“plotniques?”) you might use as Storyteller Extraordinaire to get the motherfucking job done. Let us begin.
The Basic Vanilla Tried-And-True Outline
The basic and essential outline. Numbers, Roman numerals, letters. Items in order. Separated out by section if need be (say, Act I, Act II, Act III). Easy-peazy Lyme-diseasey.
The Reverse Outline
Start at the end, instead. Write it down. “Sir Pimdrip Chicory of Bath slays the dragon-badger, but not before the dragon-badger bites the head off Chicory’s one true love, Lady Miss Wermathette Kildare of the Manchester Kildares.” Rewind the clock. Reverse the gears. Find out how you build to that.
Tentpole Moments
A story in your head may require certain keystone events to be part of the plot. “Betty-Sue must get sucked into the time portal outside Schenectady, because that’s why her ex-boyfriend Booboo begins to build a time machine in earnest which will accidentally unravel space-and-time.” You might have five, maybe ten of these. Write them down. These are the elements that, were they not included, the plot would fall down (like a tent without its poles). The narrative space between the tentpoles is uncharted territory.
Beginning, Middle, End
Write three paragraphs, each detailing the rough three acts found in every story: the inciting incident and outcome of the beginning (Act I), the escalation and conflict in the middle (Act II), the climactic culmination of events and the ease-down denoument of the end (Act III). You can, if you want, choose the elemental changes-in-state you might find at the end of each act, too — the pivot point on which the story shifts. This document probably isn’t more than a page’s worth of wordsmithy. Simple and elegant.
A Series Of Sequences
The saying goes that an average screenplay usually offers up eight or nine sequences (a sequence being a series of scenes that add together to form common narrative purpose, like, say, the Attack On The Death Star sequence from Star Wars or the Kevin James Makes Love To All The Animals In Order To Make The Audience Feel Shame sequence from Paul Blart, Zoo Abortion). So, chart the sequences that will go into your screenplay. If you’re writing prose, I don’t know how many sequences a novel should have — more than a film, probably (or alternately, each sequence is granted a greater conglomeration of scenes).
Chapter-By-Chapter
For novel writers, you can chart your story by its chapters. A standard outline is more about dictating plot and story without marrying oneself to narrative structure. This, however, puts the ring on that finger and locks it down tight. A chapter-by-chapter outline is visualizing the reader’s way through the novel.
Beat Sheet
This one’s for you real granular-types, the ones who want to count each grain of sand on your story’s beach (or, for a more terribleminds-esque metaphor, “count each pube on your story’s scrotum”). Chart each beat of the story in every scene. This is you writing the entire story’s plot out, but you’re writing it without much dialogue or narrative flair. It’s you laying out all the pieces. The order-of-operations made plain.
Mind-Maps
Happy blocks and bubbles connected to winding bendy spokes connected to a central topical hub. Behold: example. You can use a mind-map to chart… well, anything your mind so desires. It is, after all, a map of said mind. Sequence of events? Character arcs? Exploration of theme? Story-world ideas? Family trees? The crazy hats worn by your villains? Catchphrases? Your inchoate rage and shame made manifest? Your call.
Zero Draft
AKA, “The Vomit Draft.” Puke up the story. Just yarf it up — bleaaarrghsputter. A big ol’ Technicolor yawn. You aren’t aiming for structure. Aren’t aiming for art or even craft. This is just you getting everything onto the page so that it’s out there and can now be cleaned up. You’ve puked up the story, now it’s time to form it into little idols and totems — the heretic statuaries of your story.
In The Document, As You Go
AKA, “The Bring Your Flashlight” technique. You outline only as you go. Write a scene or chapter. Roughly sketch the next. Then write it. Onward and upward until you’ve got a proper story.
Write A Script
For those of you writing scripts, this sounds absurd. “He wants me to outline my script by writing a script? Has this guy been licking colorful toads?” Sorry, screenwriters — this one ain’t for you. Novelists, however, will find use in writing a script to get them through the plotting. Scripts are lean and mean: description, dialogue, description, dialogue. It’ll get you through the story fast — then you translate into prose.
Dialogue Pass
Let the characters talk, and nothing else. Put those squirrely fuckers in a room, lock the door, and let the story unfold. It won’t stay that way, of course. You’ll need to add… well, all the meat to the bones. But it’s a good way to put the characters forward and find their voice and discover their stories. Remember: dialogue reads fast and so it tends to write fast, too. Dialogue is like Astroglide: it lubricates the tale.
Character Arcs
Characters often have arcs — they start at A, go to B, end at C (with added steps if you’re feeling particularly saucy). Commander Jim Nipplesplitter, Jr. starts at “gruff and loyal soldier boy in the war against the Ant People” (A) and heads to “is crippled and betrayed by his country, left to die in the distant hills of the Ant Planet” (B) and ends up at “falls in love with a young Ant Squaw and he must fight to protect his ant-man larvae” (C). A character arc can track plotty bits, emotional shifts, outfit changes, whatever.
Synopsis First
You might think to write your query letter, treatment or synopsis last. Bzzt. Wrong move, donkeyface. Write it up front. It’s not etched in stone, but it’ll give you a good idea of how to stay on target with this story.
Index Cards
Index cards are a kick-ass organization tool. You can use them to do anything — list characters, track scenes, list chapters, identify emotional shifts, make little Origami throwing stars that will give your neighbors wicked-ass paper-cuts. Lay them on a table or pin ’em to a corkboard. Might I recommend John August’s “10 Hints For Index Cards?” I might, rabbit. I might. See also: the Index Card app for iOS.
Whiteboard
A whiteboard represents a great thinking space. Notes, mind-maps, character sketches, drawings of weird alien penises. Get some different color pens, chart your story in whatever way feels most appropriate.
The Crazy Person’s Notebook
Once in a while a story of mine demands a hyper-psycho notebook experience. My handwriting is messier than a garbage disposal choked with hair, but even still, sometimes I just like to put pen to paper and scribble. And I sometimes print stuff out, chop it up, and tape it into the notebook. (Example!)
Collage
You’re like, “What’s next? A shoebox diorama of the Lincoln assassination?” That’s a different blog post. Seriously, on my YA-cornpunk novel POPCORN, I took a whole corkboard and covered it in images and quotes that were relevant to the work. Then I’d just wander over there from time to time, stare at it, get my head around the story I’m telling and the feel of the world the story portrays. Surprisingly helpful.
Spreadsheets
Stare too long into the grid of a spreadsheet and you will feel your soul entangled there — a dolphin caught in a tuna net. Even still, you may find a spreadsheet very helpful. Track plots and beats to your heart’s delight. Seen JK Rowling’s spreadsheet for Harry Potter? High-res version right here.
Story Bible
Everything and anything goes into the story bible. Worldbuilding. Character descriptions. The “rules” of the story. Plot. Theme. Mood. An IKEA furniture manual. (Goddamn Allen wrenches.) The BIOSHOCK story bible was reputedly a 400+ page beast, which means that yes, your story bible may be bigger than your actual novel. The key is not to let this — or any planning technique — become an exercise in procrastination. You plan. Then you do. That’s the only way this works.
The Power Of Templates
Film and TV scripts already follow a fairly rigorous template, but you can go further afield. Look to Blake Snyder’s SAVE THE CAT beats. Or Joseph Campbell’s hero’s journey. Go weirder with the Proppian morphology of fairy tales. You may think it non-imaginative but the power of art and story lives easily within such borders as it does outside of them.
Stream Of Consciousness Story Babble
Slap on a diving bell and jump deep into the waters of the stream of consciousness. Order, you see, is sometimes born first from chaos, wriggling free from a uterus made from fractal swirls and Kamikaze squirrels. Open yourself to All The Frequencies: get into your word processor or find a blank notebook page and just scribble wantonly without regard to sense or quality. You may find your story lives in the noise and madness and that on that snowy screen you will find structure. Like a Magic Eye painting that reveals the image of a dolphin riding a motorbike and shooting Japanese whalers with twin chattering Uzis.
Visual Storyboards
Sometimes the words only come when given the bolstered boost of a visual hook. Sketch it out yourself. Get an artist friend. Find images from the Internet. Ingest some kind of dew-slick jungle mushroom and paint your story on the wall in an array of bodily fluids. Sometimes you really need to visualize the story.
The Test Drive
Take your characters, storyworld and ideas, and run them through a totally separate story. Let’s call it apocryphal, or “non-canonical.” It’s not a story you intend to keep. Not a story you want to publish. You’re just taking your story elements through their paces. Run them around a test drive. “This is where Detective Shirtless McGoggins solves the murder of the goblin seamstress.” Sure, your Detective lives in the real world, a world not populated by goblins. Fuck it, it’s just an exercise. A test run to find his voice and yours.
Pants The Shit Out Of It
All this plotting and scheming just isn’t working for you, so go ahead and pants the hell out of it. (Me? I don’t wear pants. Pants are the first tool of your oppressors.) Sometimes trying to wrestle your story into even the biggest box is just an exercise in frustration, so do what works for you and what doesn’t. Once again, however, I’ll exhort you to at least learn the skill of outlining — because eventually, someone’s going to ask for a demonstration of your ability.
* * *
Want another booze-soaked, profanity-laden shotgun blast of dubious writing advice?
Try: CONFESSIONS OF A FREELANCE PENMONKEY
$4.99 at Amazon (US), Amazon (UK), B&N, PDF
Or its sequel: REVENGE OF THE PENMONKEY
$2.99 at Amazon (US), Amazon (UK), B&N, PDF
And: 250 THINGS YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT WRITING
$0.99 at Amazon (US), Amazon (UK), B&N, PDF
alienredqueen says:
“Each pube on your story’s scrotum!” Awesome! Personally, I like the tent pole idea. I just don’t have it in me to be granular.
November 15, 2012 — 6:09 PM
Molly Dugger Brennan says:
Thank you, thank you, thank you. This is exactly what I needed, Chuck. You’re the best.
November 17, 2012 — 12:49 PM
krisadams616058633 says:
I lurv the way you write 🙂
January 18, 2013 — 9:53 AM
Joanne Macgregor says:
“The key is not to let this — or any planning technique — become an exercise in procrastination.”
Aah, yes… Been there, done that, got the index cards and research reams but not the wordcount to prove it.
April 22, 2013 — 3:15 AM
Phil says:
“Tent pole moments” – Brilliant phrase and one I’ll be using when describing some bits of our novel now.
Been plotting the story this week (http://nolanparker.wordpress.com/2013/05/21/plotting-and-planning-the-novel/) and the Rowling method was in my mind. We used post-its stuck to a window though as both of use have enough computers in our lives.
May 23, 2013 — 6:56 AM
NPA says:
Nice article, I found it funny that some of my methods were actually listed in here. Crazy persons notebook to mind mapping or just chapter to chapter. I can plot, now I just need to get enough discipline to actually finish more than one story.
July 1, 2013 — 11:55 PM
Wendie Donabie says:
Thanks Chuck … I do believe your words have set me free 🙂
July 15, 2013 — 3:43 PM
kamikinard says:
I’m a big fan of The Crazy Person’s Notebook. Of them, I have many. At least five per completed book… Didn’t know it was a thing until I read this post. Now I feel pigeonholed. Thanks a lot.
August 29, 2013 — 11:09 PM
Theresa Meyers says:
Personally, I find brainstorming a random list of scenes (some are tent poles, some are not) then using a big poster board divided into squares (one per chapter and midpoint, first turning point, second turning point and dark moment marked) and a bunch of different color sticky notes for each character/major element in the story gives me a great visual of my plot and plot holes. I can see patterns in the colored sticky notes (cue dancing magic ‘shrooms… or not). Using the rule of three also helps because I can pull up four colored sticky notes for that thing even if I don’t have a clue what the hell it is and find a place for it on the poster board. I just label it fear thing 1, fear thing 2, fear thing 3 and fear thing payoff. Eventually the spider monkeys in my cranium figure it out.
I’ve also used Spiderweb Plotting to figure out really hard to peel apart subplots in my story and figure out when and where they need to hit to make the whole story web hang together without the spiders sucking dry reader’s eyes in boredom. Each chapter or switch in character POV for shorter works is a ring (think of a bullseye) and the subplots (in various colors so I can track them) start in various points and radiate outward, or crisscross like a spiderweb. Have pics of what a spiderweb plotting board looks like for anyone interested.
September 18, 2013 — 9:56 AM
ParnassusReads says:
This is a very helpful post. I used to be in academia. I never did outlines for any of my papers, but I researched the shit out of them, to the point of getting lost in all of the research. Plotting out a story puts me in the same spot; I can plan the hell out of what I’m *going* to write, but then I get stuck and don’t know what to do with everything I’ve got. How do you bridge the gap between plotting/outlining and actually start writing? Maybe this is a topic for another post, and maybe only I can answer this for myself. Anyway, I love your blog and thanks for the great advice.
September 18, 2013 — 10:07 PM
Skylar the Fanfiction Addict says:
Haha, nice. I’m planning to do some of these. But one of the things I like to do is I take my characters and I just write out a script-type-thingamajig with them talking to me. Most of the time, they complain. Extensively. The things get pretty dang funny and they have absolutely no use whatsoever.
Other times, I shove them into a chat room and have them all chat via Instant Messaging.
And yet I have never, ever finished a regular plot line of my stories in anything but this inescapable, indefinite void of chaos and destruction that I call my mind.
Sometimes I wonder about the state of my own sanity…
September 22, 2013 — 11:46 PM
annabellefranklinauthor says:
LOL! I’m a dyed-in-the-wool first draft puker. What is pantsing? Is it flying by the seat of your pants? Or just writing pants?
October 9, 2013 — 11:39 AM
Ridian says:
This was a very good post. Currently I am writing a story inspired by the Mortal Instruments series, it contains vampires, werewolves, nephilim etc. In my previous stories I have found myself just writing a story and occasionally whenever I feel a lack of creativity I just go back and edit what i have done to make it sound better. But for this story i am setting up a word doc. with dot points for the main points and finer details of the story. Again this post was very helpful. (Comment if you like the Mortal Instruments)
January 3, 2014 — 9:44 PM