I do so love it when apples enter the discourse. Apples should be in our discourse every day! At least, autumnally. Because apples are good! They’re non-native but somehow quintessentially American feeling, tied into the story of local agriculture versus big agriculture, connected to indigenous orchards punished by colonizers, wound up with Johnny Appleseed, with Prohibition, with the propaganda that pushed apple out of the sinner’s circle of cider production and into As American as Apple Pie (even though apple pie isn’t even American). It’s really why I wrote Black River Orchard, in part — there’s just so much to talk about, and some of it is really, really fucked up.

Anyway, so when you have a Senate candidate like Dr. Abdul El-Sayed step onto the campaign trail and talk about (gasp) apples, you know I’m there.

In the video — which you should watch, because he’s a great speaker, honestly — he talks about liking Honeycrisp, but also how the Honeycrisp is maybe a kind of basic-ass apple. And so he and a farmer talk up a different apple, instead:

The Jonagold.

And today, the day after he posts that talk, I go to my orchard and whaaaaat do I behold? A bin of Jonagold apples.

IT WAS AS IF APPLE JESUS HIMSELF HAND-DELIVERED THEM. A miracle! Apple Jesus said, “And lo, my child, the apple you seek is the apple before you. I am the tree and I am the pippin. I am the way.” Then a worm burst out of him. The Holy Worm.

Anyway, I plucked a batch from the bin.

(These, sadly, were nestled amongst very few bins of apples. At a time when the apple bins should be overflowing, the local orchards here have little to show, given an early heat wave and a late frost this past spring that fucked up all the stonefruits and the apple harvest. Farmers are already under the boot and this certainly didn’t help them.)

Whatever the case, with this apple entering political discourse, it seems a good time to give it some munchings and crunchings, Gurgi-style.


The Jonagold: a cross between the Golden Delicious and the Jonathan apple. El-Sayed points out, this is a terrible name, and clearly the name should’ve been a Golden Jonathan. He is objectively correct on this point and I’ll brook no discussion on the subject.

I really like a Golden Delicious apple, and last year, I ate a Jonathan apple that bordered on the sublime (review here).

So, one would expect the Jonagold to be a nearly perfect apple experience.

It —

Was not?

To be upfront, it was good. Close to great! The apple I ate, from Manoff Orchard, was tasty as all get-out. It was a hair too sweet for me — that sadomasochistic electrocution kick of tartness was not present. And — to also refer to the El-Sayed video — the chew lasted just a smidge longer than the flavor, which is not the ideal Apple-Eating Situation.

It was also a weird apple because it defied exactly what I just said to you, depending on where you bit into the apple.

To clarify:

Different parts of the apple tasted different.

This is new to me.

I’ve never had this before.

The apple at the top — the broad-shouldered part of the apple — was very sweet, not very tart.

But halfway down?

The bottom of the apple?

(Technically referred to as the “calyx,” which is Latin for “apple butthole.”)

That had a tartness to match the sweetness.

Well, what the fuck was that? Is that a thing? I do not recall that ever happening to me before. That’s some Willy Wonka Everlasting Gobstopper shit. An apple that changes flavor depending on where you take your bite? That’s amazing. It’s also bullshit. What the crap.

So, the bottom half of the apple would definitely garner a higher rating then… the upper half? The apple’s ass? Great. The apple’s beefy shoulders? Merely good.

And all of this does little to resolve El-Sayed positioning the Jonagold versus the Honeycrisp — I’ve long shat upon the Honeycrisp, but truth is, it’s generally a perfectly good apple. Is the Jonagold better?

Maybe! Better is so deeply subjective, of course. I maybe liked it more. Does that mean it’s objectively better? No, of course not. A lot of people will definitely prefer the Honeycrisp. Then again, some people also like the TV show, Yellowstone. Some people listen to the band Oasis, if you’ll believe it.

Some people are full of beans. Can’t be helped.

Beyond that, what else is there to say? The Jonagold is a perfectly cromulent apple. Not particularly complex, except for the weird “flavor-by-hit-location” thing going on. It’s middle-of-the-road in terms of crunch. It was deliciously juicy. The sweetness could be described as “honeyed,” but that might be giving it a little extra-credit. It’s nice! It’s fine! It’s an apple whose parents are infinitely more accomplished and interesting — like being the child of Axl Rose and Moira Rose and you’re just, like, Gordon Rose, and you became an accountant or something who plays guitar and sings on weekends at a local bar. You’re fine! You do fine. But nobody’s really going to remember you.

Final score: I’d give the top half a 7.0, the butt half a 7.4, so I’m just gonna call this a 7.2 / 10 and take a nap

Jonagold: If you can’t hang out with one of its parents, go for it

2026 reviews so far:

Gravenstein | Hubbardston Nonesuch | Lamb Abbey Pearmain | Hewes Crab | Opalescent | Chenango Strawberry | William’s Pride | Blenheim Orange | Golden Nugget | Doctor Harvey | Kickapoo Spice | St Edmunds Pippin | Sops of Wine | Fenceline Surprise | Americus Crab | Campfield | Graham

2025 reviews:

Honeycrisp, Sweetie, Crimson Crisp, Knobbed Russet, Cortland, Maiden’s Blush, Cox’s Orange Pippin, Reine des Reinettes, Ingrid Marie, Hudson’s Golden Gem, Holstein, Suncrisp, Ashmead’s Kernel, Opalescent, Orleans Reinette, Black Gilliflower, Red Delicious Double Feature, Jonathan, Ruby Mac, Crimson Topaz, Esopus Spitzenburg, Mutsu, Hunnyz, Winesap, Stayman Winesap, Winter Banana, Ribston Pippin, Rhode Island Greening, Roxbury Russet, Opal, Cosmic Crisp, Black Oxford, Ananas Reinette, Sugarbee, Granny Smith, LucyGlo/LucyRose, Ludacrisp, D’arcy Spice, Lemonade, Wild Twist